Woods for hand tools
Reference

Woods for hand tools

Ten woods a beginner meets at a big-box store or a lumberyard, with hardness, how much each moves across its width, how it works by hand and reported dust reactions. Filter by store or hardness.

The shrinkage and movement figures come from the USDA Forest Products Laboratory's Wood Handbook (FPL-GTR-282, 2021): Table 4-3 in Chapter 4 and Table 13-5 in Chapter 13. Hardness is the Janka figure from The Wood Database, measured at 12 percent moisture content as the force to press a 0.444 in steel ball halfway into the wood (Janka Hardness). Dust reactions come from The Wood Database's chart (Wood Allergies and Toxicity), which lists reactions people have reported, not how often they happen.

WoodWhere you may find itJanka hardnessShrinkage, green to ovendry (radial / tangential, Table 4-3)Change per 1 percent moisture (radial / tangential, Table 13-5)A 5 1/2 in flatsawn board, 6 to 10 percentBy handReported dust reactions
Eastern white pineBig-box stores (when labeled) and lumberyards380 lbf (The Wood Database)2.1 / 6.1 percent0.00071 / 0.00212About 0.047 inEasy to work by hand, The Wood Database says. Paul Sellers lays out pine dovetails in pencil rather than knife, because pine compresses as the joint seats (Understanding Softwood Dovetails)Pine (genus): irritant, runny nose, asthma. The species page adds skin reactions or asthma-like symptoms in some people
Big-box "pine", species unknownBig-box stores, sold as "common board" or "select pine"Unknown: no source we found says which species these boards usually areUnknownUnknown. The movement calculator's "not sure" row uses the largest tangential figure it lists (white oak, 0.00376) and says soUp to about 0.083 in, on the "not sure" figureTreat it as pine and test on an offcut: plane a scrap and pare its end grain before planning a jointIf it is a pine, as for pine; otherwise unknown
Yellow-poplarBig-box stores and lumberyards540 lbf (The Wood Database)4.6 / 8.2 percent (Purdue's bulletin gives 4.0 / 7.1)0.00158 / 0.00289About 0.064 inVery easy to work, soft, and can leave fuzzy surfaces, The Wood Database saysPoplar: irritant, blisters, asthma, bronchitis
BasswoodLumberyards and craft suppliersAbout 410 lbf (The Wood Database, Janka Hardness)6.6 / 9.3 percent0.00230 / 0.00330About 0.073 inNo hand-tool note in our sources. The Wood Database notes its shrinkage figures are high but its movement in service is relatively low, and calls shrinkage data "an educated guess" (Dimensional Shrinkage)Not on the chart
Red oak (northern)Big-box stores and lumberyards1,220 lbf (The Wood Database)4.0 / 8.6 percent0.00137 / 0.00304About 0.067 inGood results by hand, with "mediocre dimensional stability, especially in flat sawn boards", and it stains where iron touches it wet (The Wood Database). Oak compresses more than maple or cherry, Sellers writesOak (genus): irritant, sensitizer, asthma, nasopharyngeal cancer (rare)
White oakLumberyards1,350 lbf (The Wood Database, Janka Hardness)5.6 / 10.5 percent0.00194 / 0.00376, the largest tangential figure in this tableAbout 0.083 inHard; ring-porous like red oak, so it compresses more than maple or cherry (Sellers)Oak (genus): as red oak
Hard maple (sugar maple)LumberyardsNo figure in our sources4.8 / 9.9 percent0.00165 / 0.00353About 0.078 inCompresses less than oak (Sellers). Purdue's furniture bulletin works its movement example in sugar maple (FNR-163)Maple (genus): irritant, sensitizer, asthma
Cherry (black cherry)Lumberyards, usually rough or S2S by the board footNo figure in our sources3.7 / 7.1 percent0.00126 / 0.00248About 0.055 inCompresses less than oak (Sellers)Black cherry: wheezing, giddiness
Walnut (black walnut)LumberyardsNo figure in our sources5.5 / 7.8 percent0.00190 / 0.00274About 0.060 inNo hand-tool note in our sourcesBlack walnut: irritant, sensitizer, nasopharyngeal cancer (rare)
Douglas-fir (coast)Big-box stores, mostly as construction lumber, and lumberyardsNo figure in our sources4.8 / 7.6 percent0.00165 / 0.00267About 0.059 inNo hand-tool note in our sourcesDouglas-fir: irritant, giddiness, runny nose, nausea; splinters go septic

How to read this table

  • Where you may find it is our observation Preference, not a survey: stock varies by store and region, and the label is the only thing that tells you the species. In the fictional cases, Noor and Hal buy at a big-box store and Imani at a lumberyard.
  • Shrinkage is the total from green wood to ovendry, a range no board in a home goes through. It is useful for comparing woods. Tangential shrinkage is about twice radial, the Handbook says, which is why a flatsawn board moves more across its width than a quartersawn one. Lengthwise shrinkage is only 0.1 to 0.2 percent.
  • The change per 1 percent moisture is the figure to use for a board already dry. The Handbook's formula multiplies the width by that coefficient and by the change in moisture content, and it holds only between 6 and 14 percent. Use the tangential figure for a flatsawn board, the radial for a quartersawn one, and the tangential when you are not sure Physical principle.
  • The 5 1/2 in column is that formula worked once, for the width of a 1x6, flatsawn, from 6 to 10 percent: the range the Handbook gives for interior woodwork in most of the US. The Handbook says the linear method underestimates true change by about 5 percent, and transverse shrinkage varies by about 15 percent from board to board. The movement calculator works it for your own board, climate and species.
  • Janka hardness tells you how hard a surface is to dent and roughly how much harder a wood is to chop and pare. It says nothing about how well a wood planes or how much it moves.
  • Buying sizes and grades are in Choosing wood, and the boards calculator turns nominal sizes and quarter thicknesses into actual ones.

Dust reactions

The Wood Database's chart lists reported reactions: irritant, sensitizer (a wood that can set off an allergy), asthma and others. The same page says "very few woods are actually toxic in and of themselves", but that many can cause allergic reactions in sensitive people, and that all inhaled wood dust is hazardous to long-term health. So no wood in this table is called toxic here. The U.S. National Toxicology Program lists wood dust as "known to be a human carcinogen", mainly for nasal cancers among people exposed at work (Report on Carcinogens, 15th edition, 2021). Those are workplace exposures; no source we found measures the risk from a weekend of hand work. Planes and saws make chips rather than fine dust; hand sanding still makes fine dust. Sweep or vacuum it rather than blowing it, as A shop on a table describes.

Limits

The movement figures are averages, and the column above is an estimate, not a promise that a joint or a panel will or will not crack. A reaction listed for a wood does not mean you will have it, and its absence does not mean you will not. If a wood makes you react, stop working it and ask a doctor; this page gives no medical advice.