Sharpening chisels and plane blades: a keen edge you can repeat
Flatten the back, hone the bevel with a guide on a diamond plate, raise and remove the burr, and test the edge on end grain, the same way every time.
Start here Essentials
At minimum this chapter asks you to sharpen one chisel on one double-sided diamond plate with a honing guide, and prove the edge on the end of a pine board. Everything marked Go deeper is optional on a first pass.
- Set the plate on a non-slip mat on a tray or towel, with water and a rag beside it (Setting up to sharpen).
- Flatten the back of the 1/2 in chisel until a marker hatch disappears evenly near the edge (Flattening the back).
- Set the guide to 25 degrees and hone until a burr forms along the whole edge (Two bevels and a burr).
- Add the secondary bevel and remove the burr on the fine side (Two bevels and a burr).
- Pare end grain and look at the shaving (Testing the edge).
Minimum time: about 45 minutes for a first chisel, most of it on the back; about 10 minutes for later touch-ups. Done when: the chisel pares a thin, unbroken shaving from the end of a pine board with hand pressure.
1. What sharp means Understand
A cutting edge is the line where two faces of steel meet. On a chisel or a plane blade those faces are the back (the flat face, unground, that lies against the wood or against the plane's bed) and the bevel (the angled face ground at the end). Physical principle An edge is sharp when both faces are flat and polished right up to the line where they meet, and nothing hangs off that line. Lie-Nielsen's sharpening sheet calls a sharp edge the intersection of two polished surfaces, and DMT's care sheet describes the edge as two planes meeting. Every step in this chapter serves that one sentence.
That definition explains why sharpening has two halves. Polishing the bevel alone leaves the edge only as good as the back behind it. If the back is scratched, rounded or hollow near the edge, the two faces meet in a ragged line however fine the bevel is. So the back is flattened once, carefully, and after that only the bevel needs regular work.
It also explains the burr. When you rub the bevel on an abrasive, steel is pushed off the edge and folds over onto the back as a thin, ragged lip. Lie-Nielsen calls it a wire edge. A burr is good news while you hone, because it proves the bevel has reached the edge along its whole width. It is bad news if you leave it, because it is the "something hanging off the line" in the definition: it folds into the cut, then breaks off and leaves the edge dull.
Sharpening is removing steel until the faces meet cleanly, and then removing as little as possible each time after that. The words for the stages:
- Grinding or regrinding: shaping or restoring the main bevel, or taking an edge back past a chip. Coarse abrasive, the most steel removed.
- Honing: refining the edge on a fine abrasive until the two faces meet and polish. Little steel removed.
- Grit: the size of the abrasive particles. Lower numbers are coarser and cut faster; higher numbers cut slower and leave a finer scratch pattern.
Why it matters for the reader at a kitchen table: a dull chisel needs to be pushed hard, and a hard push is what slips. Convention OSHA's workplace guidance on hand tools says the greatest hazards come from misuse and poor maintenance, and that dull tools can cause more hazards than sharp ones (OSHA 3080, Hand and Power Tools, written for employers). That is a statement about force and control. A sharp edge still cuts skin as readily as wood, and nothing here makes a tool or a method safe.
2. Setting up to sharpen
The default kit in this manual is one double-sided diamond plate and one honing guide. A diamond plate is a flat steel plate with industrial diamond bonded to its surface; a double-sided one has a coarse face and a fine face. A honing guide is a small clamp on a roller: the blade is clamped in its jaws, the roller rides on the plate, and the angle of the bevel stays the same on every stroke. The first tools lists both in the kit, and the tools and wood sheet records whether you have them.
Why this pair and not something else. It works on a kitchen counter, used dry or with water, and DMT's care sheet asks only that you wash off the metal fines and store the plate dry afterwards (DMT use and care instructions). Waterstones, the other common choice, need soaking rules and regular flattening; they are compared under Go deeper. Paul Sellers works on three diamond plates and names a double-sided coarse and superfine plate, about 250 and 1200 grit, as the cheaper option (Sellers' sharpening knowledge base). Preference One plate is enough to start. A third, finer grit can wait until you want a more polished edge.
| Face or tool | What it does | When you use it |
|---|---|---|
| Coarse side (about 250 grit on Sellers' plate) | Removes steel fast and leaves deep scratches | Flattening a back the first time; shaping the 25 degree bevel; taking an edge back past a chip |
| Fine side (about 1200 grit) | Refines the scratches and raises a small burr | Finishing the back; honing the secondary bevel; removing the burr |
| Honing guide | Holds the blade at one angle, set by how far the blade sticks out of the jaws | Every bevel stroke |
| Abrasive paper on a flat surface (optional) | Cheap, coarse grits for heavy removal | A start before you buy a plate, or regrinding a badly chipped edge |
| Marker pen | Shows where the abrasive is touching | Checking a back for flat and a bevel for angle |
Where to set up. The plate should stay put under a stroke. Put it on a non-slip mat (a piece of rubber drawer liner works) on a tray or an old towel, so the gray slurry of steel and water stays off the table and away from where food is made. Work at a comfortable height, standing, with the plate's long side running away from you. A kitchen sink is close by for rinsing; keep the swarf, the mix of steel fines and water, out of a sink with dishes in it. When you finish, wipe the plate with a wet rag, dry it and put it away. DMT adds an occasional scrub with a household cleanser and a nylon brush so the surface does not clog.
A new plate feels rough. DMT says the diamond surface seems aggressive at first and smooths after the first few sessions, with no effect on long-term performance. That is the break-in, not a fault.
Abrasive paper as a start. Sellers suggests abrasive paper on a flat surface as a temporary start, and Lie-Nielsen uses 80, 220 and 400 grit paper to regrind a primary bevel (Lie-Nielsen sharpening instructions). Wet-or-dry paper stuck to a piece of glass or a stone floor tile does the job. It wears out and has to be replaced, which is why it costs more over time.
3. Flattening the back
The back comes first, once per tool. A new chisel or blade often arrives with grinding marks on its back, and an old one may be rusty, pitted or rounded at the edge from years of careless honing. Until the back is flat and polished near the edge, no amount of bevel work gives a clean edge.
How much of the back. Convention Lee Valley's guide says a plane blade needs only the first half inch or so flat, because the blade sits on the plane's bed and only the edge does the work, while a chisel needs a completely flat back (Lee Valley, How to Sharpen). Lie-Nielsen gives the reason for chisels: chisel work needs the back as a flat reference surface, because the back is what you lay on the wood to pare a joint. Preference On a long chisel, getting the whole back flat can take more than one session. We start with the inch nearest the edge, which is all a first sharpening needs, and work further back over later sessions.
- Mark the back. Scribble a hatch of marker lines across the back near the edge. Lee Valley uses a marker hash pattern to check flatness for the same reason: the ink shows exactly where the abrasive has touched.
- Lay the back flat on the coarse side. Hold the blade with the back down, the edge toward the far end of the plate and the whole back in contact. Press down with the fingers of both hands spread over the back near the edge, not on the handle end. Lifting the handle even slightly puts a bevel on the back, which is the one thing this step must avoid.
- Rub, then look. Make ten strokes along the length of the plate, using all of it so it wears evenly, then wipe the blade and look at the ink. Where the ink is gone, the back is touching. Where it remains, there is a low spot.
- Keep going until the ink disappears evenly across the width, right up to the edge, over the area you are flattening. A small hollow in the middle that the scratches do not reach can stay, as long as the band along the edge is unbroken. A low spot at the edge or a corner cannot stay: it is where the faces will fail to meet.
- Move to the fine side and repeat until the coarse scratches are replaced by the fine ones over the same area. The back should now reflect light evenly near the edge.
Lie-Nielsen works a chisel back across the stone on and off the edge, noting that stopping short of the edge risks rounding it, and that a slightly hollow surface is better than a rounded one. On a narrow plate, take care that the edge does not tip as it runs off the end. Sellers notes that narrow chisels sharpen better in line with the plate than at the usual angle across it.
Plane blades. Flatten only the band along the edge, about the first half inch. The chipbreaker, the second piece of steel screwed to the blade in a bench plane, seats against this band, so a flat, polished band also stops shavings jamming between the two. Planing a board square covers the chipbreaker. Lie-Nielsen's Ruler Trick, a quicker way to finish a plane blade's back on a waterstone, is under Go deeper; it is for plane blades only, not chisels.
Hands and edges. Your fingers sit close to the edge on every stroke. Keep the pressure on the steel, not on the edge itself, and wipe the blade by drawing the rag from the back of the blade toward and off the edge, not along it. If you are cut, MedlinePlus says when a cut needs medical care (Cuts and puncture wounds); follow it, not us.
4. Two bevels and a burr
A chisel or plane blade carries two bevels. The primary bevel is the wide one ground at a low angle. The secondary bevel, often called a microbevel, is a narrow band at the very edge honed at a slightly steeper angle. You hone only the secondary bevel in daily use, which is why touching up an edge takes minutes rather than an hour: Lie-Nielsen says the secondary bevel concentrates all the sharpening effort on the only part of the blade that does the work.
The default angles
Convention The primary bevel is 25 degrees. Lie-Nielsen ships its blades at 25, Lee Valley sets its micro-bevel above a ground primary, and Fine Woodworking's Asa Christiana grinds most tools at 25. Makers differ on the secondary bevel, from one or two degrees above the primary to ten above. This manual's default is 30 degrees, because that is an angle a beginner can set the same way every time from one maker's published figure, and it sits between the makers' figures rather than at either end. That choice is ours, not a rule; who says what is under Go deeper.
Setting the angle. On a side-clamp honing guide of the common Eclipse style, the angle comes from how far the edge projects in front of the guide's jaws. Lie-Nielsen publishes approximate distances for that style of guide: 2 1/8 in of projection for 25 degrees and 1 9/16 in for 30 degrees, exact for a blade 1/8 in thick. Product-specific Those figures belong to that guide design. If your guide is a different design, use its maker's chart; a Veritas MK II, for example, sets its primary bevel with a knob at 12 o'clock and adds a micro-bevel with the knob at 6 o'clock (Lee Valley, Using the MK II Honing Guide). Lie-Nielsen tells owners of its own guide not to use it on diamond stones, so check what your guide's maker says about diamond plates before you start.
A thinner blade, which many older plane blades are, sits at a slightly different angle at the same projection. That does not matter. Physical principle DMT's care sheet says keeping a constant angle matters more than matching a particular one. What makes an edge repeatable is setting it the same way each time. Lie-Nielsen's way to guarantee that is a stop block: a scrap of wood with a block glued at the projection distance, so you set the blade against the block instead of measuring with a rule. Make one with two stops, one for 25 and one for 30, and keep it with the plate.
Honing the primary bevel and raising a burr
- Clamp the blade square in the guide at the 25 degree projection, back down, edge square to the guide's sides. A blade clamped crooked hones a crooked edge.
- Check with the marker. Color the whole bevel and make two strokes on the fine side. If the ink comes off across the full bevel, heel to edge, the guide matches the bevel. If it comes off only at the edge or only at the heel, the existing bevel is at another angle and the coarse side will have to reshape it.
- Hone on the coarse side. Light downward pressure with two or three fingers just behind the edge, back-and-forth strokes the length of the plate. Lee Valley's MK II instructions use the same light pressure. Count the strokes so you can repeat them on the next blade.
- Feel for the burr. Every ten strokes, draw a fingertip off the back of the blade, from the body of the blade across and off the edge. A burr catches the skin like a tiny rough lip. Check at both corners and the middle. Keep honing until it can be felt along the whole width; Lie-Nielsen hones until a wire edge forms on the back. A burr at one corner only means the guide or your pressure is tipping the blade.
- Repeat on the fine side until its scratches cover the bevel and a smaller burr forms again along the edge.
The secondary bevel and removing the burr
- Reset the projection to 30 degrees using the stop block, without unclamping the blade from square.
- Hone on the fine side until a narrow, bright band forms at the edge and a burr can be felt along the whole width. On a freshly honed primary this takes only a few strokes. The band should run parallel to the edge; Lie-Nielsen notes that if the edge is square and your pressure even, it will.
- Remove the burr. Take the blade out of the guide, lay the back flat on the fine side as you did when flattening it, and make a few light strokes. Lee Valley's MK II instructions finish the same way, on the finest grit. Check with your fingertip. If the burr has flipped back to the bevel side, give the secondary bevel one or two light strokes in the guide and then the back again, with less pressure each time, until nothing can be felt.
The angles in this chapter are makers' conventions, not physical rules. They do not tell you that an edge is good; only the test on end grain does that, and only for that edge on that day. A chipped, cracked or badly out-of-square edge may need more coarse work than a beginner wants to do by hand. A local sharpening service can regrind it, and the manual does not judge whether a particular old chisel is worth the time.
5. Testing the edge, and keeping it
Test it The test this manual uses is paring end grain. End grain is the cut end of a board, where the wood fibers point at you like the ends of drinking straws. It is the hardest direction to cut cleanly, which makes it an honest judge: a dull edge crushes and tears the fibers, and a sharp one slices them. Clamp an offcut of pine upright, or hold it on the bench hook (Make a bench hook this weekend), set the chisel flat on the end grain, bevel up, and push it across with hand pressure only, no mallet. Pass: a thin, continuous shaving and a surface that looks polished. Fail: crumbs, a torn surface, or a streak where one part of the edge scraped instead of cut.
A streak at one spot means a nick or a burr left at that spot. A torn surface across the whole width usually means the bevel did not reach the edge, so the burr was not raised everywhere. When it goes wrong lists these signs with their usual causes. Write the result in the sharpening log: tool, angles, grits, date and the end-grain result. Over a few sessions the log tells you how often each tool needs honing.
The ten-minute routine
Once a tool has a flat back and a 25 degree primary, keeping it sharp is short. Set the projection to 30 degrees with the stop block, hone on the fine side until a burr forms along the edge, remove the burr on the back, test on end grain. Lie-Nielsen notes that a blade honed often may need only the finishing stone to touch up the bevel. Lee Valley says a microbevel can be honed about 10 to 20 times before it needs regrinding, for its own small micro-bevel. Hone when the tool starts to need more push or leaves a duller surface, not on a schedule.
When to regrind
Each honing makes the secondary bevel a little wider. When it has grown wide enough that it takes many more strokes to raise a burr, Lie-Nielsen's instruction is to re-establish the 25 degree primary on coarse abrasive, leaving about 1/64 in of the secondary bevel showing because it helps keep the edge square. Then hone a fresh secondary bevel as before. On a diamond plate, regrinding is the coarse-side work from the honing steps above.
A chipped edge
A chip is a missing piece of the edge, often from a chisel used to pry or a blade dropped on a hard floor. The edge has to be ground back past the bottom of the chip. DMT says to start a damaged edge on an extra-coarse plate and step through the grits from there. On a double-sided plate, that means a long session on the coarse side at 25 degrees, checking the edge square with a try square as you go, until the bevel meets the back below the chip. Coarse paper at 80 grit, which Lie-Nielsen uses for regrinding, is faster. A chip deeper than about 1/16 in is where a sharpening service starts to be worth it; that threshold is our judgment, not a source's.
Plane blades and chisels together. The method is the same for both. Two differences: the plane blade's back needs only its edge band flat, and its edge can be straight or very slightly curved (camber, under Go deeper). For the chisel, the edge must be square to its sides, because you will pare to a knife line with it.
Rust. After sharpening, Lie-Nielsen recommends wiping the steel with oil to prevent rust. That matters most in a damp basement or an unheated garage.
Go deeper 6. What the makers and teachers say
The figures differ because each source sharpens for its own tools and its own stones, and each is right on its own terms. The table puts the published figures side by side.
| Source | Primary bevel | Secondary bevel | Abrasives |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lee Valley, How to Sharpen | The blade's ground bevel | 1 or 2 degrees above the primary, about the first millimeter, honed 10 to 20 times before regrinding | Checks flatness on a 1200 diamond plate or 8000 waterstone; 8000 enough for most work, and finer edges are more fragile |
| Lie-Nielsen, Sharpening Instructions | 25 degrees | 35 degrees (a 10 degree microbevel); its bench plane sheet says 5 to 10 degrees above | 1,000 and 8,000 to 10,000 waterstones; Arkansas oilstones acceptable; not diamond stones with its guide |
| Fine Woodworking (Asa Christiana, 2012) | 25 degrees | 27 or 28 degrees, higher for chisels struck with a mallet | 1,000, 4,000 and 8,000 |
| Paul Sellers | Freehand, not a guide angle (his method pages were not read) | Not read | Diamond plates at 250, 600 and 1200 plus a strop; a double-sided 250 and 1200 as the cheaper option |
| This manual's default | 25 degrees | 30 degrees, set by projection | One double-sided diamond plate |
A steeper secondary bevel leaves more steel behind the edge, which is why Christiana raises it for chisels driven with a mallet, and why Lie-Nielsen suggests 45 to 50 degrees on a bevel-up plane for difficult grain. A lower angle cuts with less effort but leaves a thinner edge. Lee Valley adds that the finest edges are also the more fragile ones.
Waterstones. Synthetic stones lubricated with water, typically in a 1,000 and an 8,000 grit pair, are the makers' standard (Fine Woodworking, How to Use a Honing Guide). They cut fast and polish finely, and they wear hollow. Lie-Nielsen calls flat stones essential and flattens them after every session on 100 to 220 grit wet-or-dry paper or a lapping plate, about 15 to 20 strokes until a pencil cross-hatch disappears. Soaking rules depend on the stone: Shapton says its Kuromaku stones need no soaking except a 5 to 6 minute pre-soak on first use, warns against soaking them for more than 30 minutes, and should not meet hot water or detergent; once oil is used on a stone, only oil (Shapton Kuromaku FAQ). Other makers' stones are meant to be soaked. Follow the maker of the stone you own.
The Ruler Trick. Lie-Nielsen finishes a plane blade's back by laying a thin steel ruler, about .020 in thick, along one edge of the finishing stone and honing the back across it, which tilts the blade by less than a degree and polishes only the very edge. The edge goes no more than 1/2 in onto the stone, about ten passes. It is for plane blades only. Lie-Nielsen says not to use it on chisels, which need a flat back as a reference, and Lee Valley's call for completely flat chisel backs points the same way.
Freehand honing. Christiana writes that roughly half the teachers he knows teach freehand sharpening, holding the angle by feel, and that rocking the blade rounds the tip. Sellers sharpens freehand to a slightly convex bevel. It is faster once learned and needs no guide; we did not read a source that teaches it step by step, so we name it and leave it.
Stropping. A strop is leather, usually charged with a polishing compound, that the edge is drawn across to polish it after the finest plate. Sellers uses one. No source we read gives figures for it, so we name it without a method.
Camber. A smoothing plane blade honed with a very slight curve across its width leaves no ridges where the blade's corners would otherwise dig in. Lie-Nielsen produces a camber of .002 to .005 in by pressing harder on each outside edge for a set count of strokes, then less toward the center, and notes that the curve needed is only a bit bigger than the shaving, usually under .002 in for a smoothing plane. Shoulder and jointer planes, and a plane used on a shooting board, need a straight edge.
7. See it See it
Hal's father's chisels. Hal (fictional), 71, inherited four chisels with chipped edges and a Stanley No. 4 plane with surface rust. He starts with the 1/2 in chisel, the one the tote's joints use most. Known: the chip on its edge is about 1/32 in deep, measured against a steel rule; the back is rusty for its first inch; he owns a double-sided diamond plate and a side-clamp guide. Assumed: the back is not flat, because old tools rarely are (his assumption, checked with the marker in the first ten minutes: the ink stays in a stripe across the middle, so the back is slightly hollow there and fine at the edge). Open: whether to grind out the chips on all four chisels himself or send them to a sharpening service. Hal settles it by timing the first one: the chip takes about 25 minutes on the coarse side at 25 degrees, checked square with his try square every few minutes. He decides the others are worth doing himself over a week of evenings. He hones the 30 degree secondary bevel, removes the burr, and pares a pine offcut in his unheated garage at about 45 F. The first shaving leaves a streak at the left corner; he feels a burr there, removes it, and the second shaving comes off whole. He wipes the chisel with oil before hanging it up, and writes the angles, grits, date and "second try clean" in the sharpening log.
- Sharpening Instructions, Lie-Nielsen: a maker's whole method in four pages, with the projection chart for side-clamp guides and the Ruler Trick.
- How to Sharpen, Lee Valley: flattening backs with a marker, and how much of a plane blade's back matters.
- Use and Care Instruction, DMT: which grit to start a damaged or neglected edge on, and how to keep a diamond plate clean.
- Sharpening, Paul Sellers' knowledge base: one teacher's diamond plate setup and the cheaper double-sided option.
8. Practice Practice
Minimum: one 1/2 in chisel with its back flattened near the edge, honed at 25 and 30 degrees, deburred, and tested on end grain. Time: about 45 minutes for the first chisel; about 15 minutes for each further tool once you have the stop block. Materials: a double-sided diamond plate, a honing guide, a non-slip mat, a tray or old towel, water in a spray bottle, a rag, a marker, a steel rule, a scrap for the stop block, and an offcut of pine at least 2 in wide.
- Make the stop block. Clamp a blade in the guide at 2 1/8 in of projection, set the guide on a scrap board and glue or screw a stop where the edge touches. Do the same at 1 9/16 in. Label each stop with its angle.
- Flatten the chisel's back near the edge, coarse side then fine, checking with the marker.
- Hone the 25 degree primary on the coarse side until a burr runs the whole width, then on the fine side.
- Hone the 30 degree secondary on the fine side and remove the burr on the back.
- Pare the pine's end grain. If the shaving breaks or streaks, find the spot on the edge, feel for a burr there, and repeat the secondary bevel and deburring.
- Log it in the sharpening log.
- Sharpen the plane blade the same way (Go deeper; optional). Flatten only the half inch along its edge, and test it in the plane on a board's edge as described in Planing a board square.
9. Your setup Your setup
10. Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- Does the marker test show the back touching the plate along the whole edge, corners included?
- Did you feel a burr along the whole width before moving to the next grit or bevel?
- Is the secondary bevel a narrow band of even width, parallel to the edge?
- Is the chisel's edge square to its sides, checked with a try square?
- Did the edge pare a thin, unbroken shaving from pine end grain with hand pressure?
- Is the projection for each angle recorded, on a stop block or in the log, so you can set it again?
Worked example
Noor (fictional) works at her kitchen table on a 30 by 48 in dining table with a veneered top, so she puts the plate on drawer liner on a baking tray. Her new 1/2 in chisel's back clears the marker evenly at the edge after about fifteen minutes on the coarse side. Her first end-grain test, on an offcut of her 1x6, crumbles across the middle. Checking the criteria, she finds she moved to the fine side before the burr reached the middle of the edge: her pressure was on the left. She goes back to the coarse side with her fingers centered, feels the burr across the whole width, hones the secondary bevel and deburrs. The second test gives a curled, continuous shaving. Her log line reads: 1/2 in chisel, 25 and 30, coarse and fine, first test failed (no burr in the middle), second clean.
Common mistakes
- Lifting the handle when flattening the back. It puts a small bevel on the back, and the edge then does not meet cleanly. The marker shows it: the ink comes off only at the very edge.
- Moving on before the burr runs the whole width. The part of the edge without a burr was not reached. The end-grain test shows a tear or crumble at that spot.
- Leaving the burr on. The first cut is clean and the second is dull, because the burr folded into the edge and broke off.
- Clamping the blade crooked in the guide. The edge comes out skewed, which matters for a chisel that pares to a knife line. Check the edge with a square after the first coarse strokes.
- Pressing hard. Heavy pressure tips the guide and digs the corners. Light, even pressure and more strokes do the same work with a straighter edge.
- Changing the angle each session. Every change makes the coarse side reshape the whole bevel again. Set the projection from the stop block every time.
What is still unresolved
- How a sharp plane blade is set in the plane, and how sharp is sharp enough for planing: Planing a board square.
- Whether an old chisel or plane is worth sharpening, and what to check before buying one: buying or inheriting used tools.
- A chisel with a cracked blade or a split handle is not a sharpening problem; a tool dealer or sharpening service can say whether it can be repaired.