Planing a board square
Sawing and planing

Planing a board flat, straight and square

Set up a bench plane, read the grain, flatten a face checked with winding sticks, plane an edge square to it and true the ends on a shooting board.

Start here Essentials

At minimum this chapter asks you to set up one plane and give one board a flat face and a square edge. Everything marked Go deeper is optional on a first pass.

  1. Hone the blade, then set the chipbreaker and depth (Sharpening, then Setting up a bench plane).
  2. Read the grain on the board's edge to choose which way to plane (Reading grain).
  3. Plane one face until a straightedge shows no light across it and winding sticks sight level (Flattening a face).
  4. Plane one edge square to that face (An edge square to the face).
  5. Mark the face and the edge as the references every later mark is taken from (An edge square to the face).

Minimum time: about 30 minutes to set up the plane, then about 30 minutes for one short board. Done when: the board has one flat face and one straight, square edge, both marked, checked with a square and winding sticks.

1. Setting up a bench plane Understand

A plane is a chisel held at a fixed angle and a fixed depth. The body holds the blade so it cannot dig in or skate off, and the flat bottom, the sole, rides on the high spots of the wood and lets the blade shave them off until there are none. That is why a plane makes a surface flat and a chisel by itself does not.

A bench plane is the family of general planes worked on a bench or table: the No. 4 smoothing plane in this manual's kit, about 9 to 10 in long, and the longer No. 5 jack plane are the two a beginner meets. In both, the blade sits bevel down on an inclined casting called the frog. Product-specific Lie-Nielsen's bench plane sheet gives the standard figures: the blade is ground at 25 degrees and bedded at 45 degrees, bevel down (Lie-Nielsen bench plane instructions). A Stanley or Record No. 4 of any age is built the same way.

PartWhat it doesHow it is set
Blade (also called the iron)CutsHoned as in Sharpening; its back's edge band flat
Chipbreaker (cap iron)Screwed to the blade; bends the shaving up and out so it breaks before it can split ahead of the edgeAbout 1/16 in back from the cutting edge for general work, closer for the finest cuts
FrogThe bed the blade rests onMoved forward or back to open or close the mouth
MouthThe slot in the sole the blade comes throughNarrower for fine cuts in difficult grain, wider for thick shavings
Lever capClamps the blade and chipbreaker to the frogFirm enough to hold, loose enough to adjust
Depth adjuster (the brass wheel behind the frog)Moves the blade out of or into the soleA hair's projection to start
Lateral leverTilts the blade side to sideUntil the edge is parallel to the sole

The setup, in order

  1. Take the blade out and hone it. Lift the lever cap's cam, slide the cap off, and lift out the blade with its chipbreaker. Separate the two and sharpen the blade.
  2. Set the chipbreaker. Product-specific Lie-Nielsen says to set its end about 1/16 in from the cutting edge for general work and closer for the finest smoothing. Its front edge has to bear tightly on the blade's back along the whole width. Test it Hold the pair up to a light: if light shows between them at the front, shavings will jam there, and the chipbreaker's front edge needs truing on the plate. Fine Woodworking's Chris Gochnour describes the chipbreaker's job as deflecting the shaving up and out (Fine Woodworking, Handplaning 101).
  3. Leave the frog where it is, for now. The frog's position sets the mouth. Lee Valley leaves the mouth slightly wide and closes it only after the blade is finally adjusted; Gochnour advances the blade until it barely projects, then moves the frog. How the frog is moved depends on the plane: on Bedrock-style frogs (Stanley Bedrock, Lie-Nielsen, Clifton) Gochnour loosens two rear screws and turns a central one, and on other designs the frog screws sit under the blade. Preference On a first setup, leave an old plane's frog alone unless shavings jam in the mouth. It is one less thing changing at once.
  4. Put the blade back and set the lever cap. Gochnour sets lever-cap tension just enough to hold the blade while still letting the adjusters move it; Lee Valley warns against overtightening. If the depth wheel is stiff to turn, the cap is too tight; if the blade shifts in a cut, too loose.
  5. Set the depth by sighting. Turn the plane over and sight along the sole from the front, toward a window or a white wall. Turn the depth wheel until the edge just shows as a thin dark line above the sole. Lee Valley describes the same sighting method (Lee Valley, Setting the Blade).
  6. Set the lateral by test cuts at both corners. Lee Valley runs a scrap about 1/8 in thick, 1 in wide and 2 to 3 in long past the left corner of the blade and then the right, and moves the lateral lever until both shavings match. On a board edge the same check works: take a pass along the left half of the edge, then the right half, and compare the shavings.

The first shavings should be thin enough to see light through, and full width only when you want them to be. Advance the blade a little at a time. A blade set too deep stalls in the cut and tears the wood; it is the most common reason a first plane "does not work."

An old plane. Preference Paul Sellers calls a standard secondhand No. 4 the best example of a used buy, and says the sole of a bad one takes him about 15 minutes to flatten and that in his view a bench plane's sides do not need squaring to the sole (Sellers, You Don't Need Much). Whether a particular old sole needs work shows up in use: a plane that cuts at the toe and heel of a board but skips the middle, or will not take a thin, even shaving with a sharp blade, may have a sole that is not flat. Checking a used plane before buying it is in buying or inheriting used tools; flattening a sole is beyond this chapter.

2. Reading grain, and what to do about tearout

Tearout is the rough, torn patch left when the plane lifts fibers out of the surface instead of slicing them. It happens when you plane against the grain. Physical principle Wood fibers rarely run exactly parallel to a board's face; they run at a slight angle to it, so they rise to the surface along its length. Popular Woodworking's grain article puts it simply: planing against the grain causes tearout (Popular Woodworking, Reading Grain Direction).

Here is why direction matters. The shaving in front of the blade tends to split ahead along the fibers. If the fibers rise toward the surface in the direction you are pushing, the split runs out to the surface and the shaving breaks off cleanly. If they dive down into the board, the split runs down below the cut, and the plane lifts out a chunk. Choosing wood explains how the grain got there.

How to read it

  • Look at the edge. To plane a face, look at the board's edge next to it. The lines of the grain run at a slight angle to the face. Plane in the direction in which those lines run up toward the face you are planing.
  • Do not trust the face alone. Popular Woodworking warns that the oval and line patterns on a board's face can mislead.
  • Split a scrap. Splitting an offcut with a chisel shows the true fiber direction, which the same article recommends when the clues disagree.
  • Let the plane tell you. Test it Take a light pass. If the surface tears, turn the board end for end and try again. On many boards the grain reverses partway along, and one end planes cleanly one way and the other end the other way.

When it still tears

Work down this list, cheapest first. Test it Each one is a change you try and judge by the surface.

  1. Plane from the other end. The grain may have changed direction.
  2. Hone the blade. A dull edge pushes fibers instead of cutting them.
  3. Take a finer cut. Retract the blade until the shaving is barely there.
  4. Set the chipbreaker closer. Lie-Nielsen sets it closer than 1/16 in for the finest smoothing, for this reason.
  5. Skew the plane. Hold the plane at an angle to the direction of travel while pushing straight along the board. The blade then meets the fibers at a slicing angle.

When it goes wrong keeps this list with the other planing faults.

3. Flattening a face

One face comes first, because everything else is measured from it. A board can be out of flat in four ways, each named after what you see:

ShapeWhat you seeWhere you plane
CupHollow across the width, like a shallow troughOn the hollow face, the two long edges first; on the round face, the crown along the middle
BowCurved along the length, like a skiOn the hollow face, the two ends; on the round face, the middle
Twist (also called wind)Two diagonally opposite corners high; the board rocks on a flat surfaceThe two high corners, with diagonal passes
Local high spotsA hump the straightedge rocks onThe hump, with short strokes, then full passes

The two checks

A straightedge. The edge of a steel rule, a known-straight strip, or the edge of the plane's sole laid on the board. Lay it across the width at both ends and the middle, along the length, and along both diagonals, and look for light under it. Light under the middle means a hollow; a straightedge that rocks means a hump. Mark high spots in pencil as you find them.

Winding sticks. A matched pair of straight, parallel sticks, one laid across each end of the board at right angles to its length. Fine Woodworking's Doug Peterman describes crouching and sighting from several feet away across the tops of the sticks: if the two top edges line up, the ends of the board lie in one plane (Fine Woodworking, Use Winding Sticks to Ensure Flat Stock). If one stick tilts against the other, the board is twisted, and the high corners are the ones where the far stick rises above the near one. Physical principle The sticks work because they are longer than the board is wide, so they magnify a small twist into a tilt you can see. Peterman gives an example: a 1 degree twist in the stiles of a 12 in wide frame-and-panel door makes one corner stand out 3/16 in. Contrasting woods help, he says; a darkened top edge on the far stick does the same. Making a pair is this chapter's practice.

Limits

Check a board before you plane it. Planing a cupped or twisted board flat takes wood off its thickness, and a badly distorted board may not leave the thickness the part needs. Set a marking gauge to the thickness you need, gauge a line round the edges from the face you intend to flatten, and look at whether flattening would cut below the line anywhere. If it would, choose another board or another part of this one rather than plane it thin. The checks in this chapter tell you a face is flat today; they say nothing about whether the board will stay that way when the room's humidity changes, which Choosing wood covers.

Holding the board

A plane needs the board held still against the push. Without a vise, the planing board does it: Popular Woodworking's Steve Branam describes an 18 in square board with thin stops along its back and left edges and a thicker strip underneath at the front that hooks over the table edge, so the push of the plane holds the board in place (Popular Woodworking, Beyond the Vise: Planing Boards). It takes parts up to about 16 in long. You plane toward the stops. A shop on a table shows how to make one and hook it on a dining table without marking the top. A board that rocks on the planing board springs under the plane; slip thin wedges under the low corners so it sits still.

The sequence

  1. Choose the better face to flatten first: the one with fewer defects, or the one that will be on the inside of the tote if you want the outside to keep more thickness.
  2. Check and mark. Straightedge and winding sticks; pencil on the high corners and humps.
  3. Take down the high spots. For twist, plane diagonally from one high corner toward the other. For cup on the hollow face, plane along the two edges. Keep the shavings light.
  4. Plane across the whole face. Diagonal passes in one direction, then the other, overlapping, so the plane levels the whole surface.
  5. Finish along the grain. Full-length passes, overlapping by about half the blade width, in the direction the grain allows. These remove the diagonal marks.
  6. Check again after every few passes. Stop as soon as the straightedge shows no light in any direction and the winding sticks sight level. More planing past that point only makes the board thinner.

Pencil scribbles across the face show progress: when every scribble has been touched by the plane, you have planed the whole surface. On a board's last passes, press on the plane's front knob as you start a stroke and on the rear handle as you finish it, so the plane does not dip off the ends.

4. An edge square to the face, then width and thickness

The flat face is the face side. Next comes the face edge: one edge planed straight along its length and square to the face side. Together they are the board's references, and every later mark is gauged or squared from one of them. Marking out explains the reference faces and the traditional marks for them.

Planing the edge

Hold the board on edge. A short part, such as any of Noor's tote parts at 10 3/4 in or less, can be planed lying flat on the shooting board in the next section, which also squares an edge. A longer board is clamped on edge to a table leg or to the side of the planing board; A shop on a table shows the setups.

  1. Read the grain on the face, which is now the edge's neighbor, and plane in the direction the lines rise toward the edge.
  2. Check straight. Sight along the edge or lay the straightedge on it. A hollow edge is planed with short strokes on the two high ends, then one full-length pass.
  3. Check square. Hold a try square's stock against the face side and its blade across the edge, at several places along the length. Light under one side of the blade means that side of the edge is high.
  4. Correct square. Plane the high side. Test it Moving the plane over so the blade's center runs on the high side takes more there, because the blade's edge is set with a slight lateral tilt or a little camber; a few lateral-lever adjustments toward the high side do the same.
  5. Mark both references. The face-side mark on the face, pointing to the face edge, and the edge mark on the edge, as Marking out shows.

Width and thickness by gauge lines

Numbers come off the board here and gauge lines take over. A marking gauge is a fence on a beam with a pin or wheel that scores a line parallel to whatever the fence runs against. Dean Jansa's article in Popular Woodworking describes the gauge as transferring a measurement from one board to another without numbers, gauging from the face side so assembled parts sit flush, starting with a light pass with the pin barely engaged and the pin trailing, and using gauge lines to plane boards to an even thickness (Popular Woodworking, Mystery of the Marking Gauge).

  • Width. Set the gauge to the part's width, from the story stick or from the part it must match. Run the fence along the face edge and gauge a line on both faces. Saw close to it if there is much to remove (Sawing to a line), then plane the second edge down to the lines, checking it straight. It is square if the lines on both faces are reached together.
  • Thickness. Set the gauge to the thickness, run the fence on the face side and gauge a line all round the edges and ends. Plane the second face down until the lines are just split, checking with the straightedge as you go.

Big-box boards arrive surfaced on both faces and both edges, and for a tote you often need no thickness planing: you flatten one face just enough, take an edge square and work to width. Preference What matters is that parts which meet are the same thickness where they meet, which is easier to check with the gauge than with a rule.

5. Ends on the shooting board

A sawn end is close to the line but rarely square in both directions. A shooting board trues it: a platform that holds the work at 90 degrees to a track, with a plane laid on its side running in the track. Christopher Schwarz describes it as trimming in increments of about .001 in and squaring ends that have 1/32 in or less to remove; he uses a heavy plane with a blade sharpened straight across, and chamfers the far corner of the work with a chisel so the last fibers do not break away (Popular Woodworking, What's a Shooting Board). He also notes that a bench hook can serve as a shooting board, so the hook from Make a bench hook this weekend can do the first ends.

David Finck's shooting board in Fine Woodworking is 18 in long by 11 in wide from 3/4 in plywood, and he names the two things that must be right: the stop must be square, and flush with the edge the plane runs against. He corrects an out-of-square stop with masking tape shims, and resets the stop when the gap to the plane's sole reaches about 1/32 in (Fine Woodworking, Build a Shooting Board).

  1. Saw to just outside the knife line on the waste side.
  2. Lay the part face side down against the stop, with the end just past the edge of the platform.
  3. Run the plane on its side along the track with light shavings, holding the work firmly against the stop with your other hand, fingers well away from the track.
  4. Stop when the knife line is split, and check the end with the try square from the face side and the face edge.

The same move squares the edge of a short part. For a set of parts that must match in length, such as the tote's two sides, shoot one, mark the second from it, and shoot the second to the mark.

Hands. On a shooting board the blade runs past the edge of the platform, where the hand holding the work wants to be. Keep that hand on the work behind the stop, and the plane hand on the plane. If you are cut, MedlinePlus says when a cut needs care (Cuts and puncture wounds).

Go deeper 6. Other planes, steeper angles and thicknessing by hand

A jack plane for rough work. The No. 5 jack plane, about 14 in long, is the plane The English Woodworker's kit starts with. It can be set for heavier shavings than a smoothing plane, to take a rough board down before the No. 4 finishes it; we found no maker's figures for that setup, so we give none. Its longer sole also bridges more of a hollow, which helps on an edge. A No. 4 alone does all the work on a tote; it is slower on a rough board.

Steeper angles for difficult grain. The steeper the angle at which the blade meets the wood, the more it scrapes and the less it can lift fibers. Lie-Nielsen offers optional 50 and 55 degree frogs for difficult woods, and its sharpening sheet suggests honing a bevel-up plane's blade at 45 to 50 degrees for difficult grain. A back bevel, a small bevel honed on the blade's back, raises the cutting angle of a bevel-down plane in the same way; we found no maker's figures for it, so we name it only.

How flat is a new plane? Product-specific Lie-Nielsen says its bench plane bodies are flat and square to .0015 in. That is one maker's specification for its own planes, not a standard an old plane has to meet; a plane is flat enough when it takes a thin, even shaving across the whole width of a board.

Thicknessing a whole board by hand. When a project needs a thickness no store sells, or boards come rough from a lumberyard, the method in this chapter scales up: flatten one face, gauge the thickness all round from it, and plane the other face to the lines. The English Woodworker's spoon rack series starts by hand-thicknessing pre-planed pine. On a wide board it is long, warm work with a jack plane, and the Limits above apply with more force: check that the thickness is there before you start.

7. See it See it

Fictional example

Hal's father's Stanley No. 4. Hal (fictional), 71, works in his unheated attached garage. Known: the plane has all its original parts and surface rust; there is plenty of blade above the rear handle; his yellow-poplar sides are 18 in long, more than the 16 in an 18 in planing board takes, so he clamps a stop strip to his table instead. Assumed: the frog is where his father left it and the mouth is about right, which is Hal's assumption; he leaves it alone. Open: whether the sole is flat enough, settled by the plane's own results. He hones the blade, sets the chipbreaker about 1/16 in back, sights the depth, and runs test shavings at both corners on a poplar edge. The left shaving is thicker, so he moves the lateral lever until both match. On his first face the plane cuts at both ends and skips the middle; the straightedge shows the board is hollow there, so the skip is the board's shape, not the plane's. Once that face checks flat, the plane takes a thin shaving the full width of it, which settles the open question: the sole is good enough. Poplar can leave a fuzzy surface; a freshly honed blade and a finer cut clean it up. He wipes the plane with oil before leaving it in the garage.

8. Practice: a pair of winding sticks Practice

Winding sticks are the first project of The Hand Tool School's Semester 1 (The Hand Tool School, Semester 1), and they suit this chapter because making them is the whole skill: a face flat, two edges straight, square and parallel, and a pair that checks itself.

Minimum: one board about 16 in long with one face flat and one edge straight and square to it, checked with a straightedge, a try square and a borrowed pair of straight strips used as winding sticks. Time: about 2 hours for the pair, over one or two sessions. Materials: an offcut of straight-grained board about 16 in long and at least 4 in wide (a piece of the tote stock left over, such as Noor's 1x6 or Hal's poplar), the No. 4 plane, a marking gauge, a try square, a steel rule for a straightedge, the ryoba, a pencil and a dark marker.

  1. Flatten one face of the board as in Flattening a face, with the straightedge only; you have no winding sticks yet.
  2. Plane one edge straight and square to that face. This edge is the top of the first stick.
  3. Gauge the first stick's height, about 1 3/4 in, from that edge on both faces. Rip it off on the waste side with the ryoba's rip teeth and plane the sawn edge down to the gauge lines.
  4. Make the second stick the same way. Plane the board's newly sawn edge straight and square, gauge 1 3/4 in from it, rip and plane to the lines.
  5. Check them against each other. Test it Stand the two sticks on edge, back to back, top edges together, and hold them up to a light. No light between them means both edges match. Turn one end for end and look again: if they still match, both are straight, not just bent the same way.
  6. Darken the top edge of one stick with the marker, so the pair contrast when you sight across them.
  7. Use them on the next board you flatten, and log the result in the practice log.

9. Your setup Your setup

10. Check your work Check your work

Criteria

  • Does the plane take a thin shaving of even thickness across the width of the blade?
  • Does the straightedge show no light across, along or diagonally on the face side?
  • Do the winding sticks sight level across both ends?
  • Is the face edge straight along its length and square to the face side at both ends and the middle?
  • Are the face and edge marked, so you know which surfaces are the references?
  • Where you planed to gauge lines, are the lines just split all the way round?

Worked example

Imani (fictional), who is left-handed, works at a shared bench in her rented basement, with a dehumidifier holding the room at about 55 percent humidity. Her cherry came from the lumberyard surfaced two sides at 13/16 in. Her open question was whether to plane it to 3/4 in. She flattens one face of a side blank and checks it against the criteria: the straightedge shows a little cup, and the winding sticks show one corner high. After the face is flat, she gauges 3/4 in round the edges and finds the line sits about 1/16 in below the second face all round. Planing four tote walls and a divider down to the lines is about an evening's work. Nothing in her tote needs 3/4 in: the parts only have to match each other. She decides to keep the 13/16 in thickness, flattening each face just enough, and enters 13/16 in as the stock thickness in the cut list calculator. That is her choice, and either answer was sound. She planes left to right, the mirror of the photos she has seen, and moved the planing board's side stop to the right-hand edge so she still planes toward it.

Common mistakes

  • The blade set too deep. The plane stalls, chatters or tears. Retract it until the shaving is thin, then advance in small steps.
  • Planing before checking. Without the straightedge and sticks you plane the wrong places and lose thickness. Check, mark, plane, check.
  • Planing against the grain and pressing harder. The tearout gets deeper. Turn the board around, take a finer cut, then hone.
  • Squaring the edge to the wrong face. If the square's stock rides on an unplaned face, the edge is square to nothing in particular. Check from the face side, and mark it first.
  • A chipbreaker that does not seat. Shavings jam under it and the plane stops cutting. Look for light between it and the blade.
  • Planing past flat. Every extra pass makes the board thinner. Stop when the checks pass.

What is still unresolved

  • Whether the board will stay flat as the seasons change: Choosing wood, and the movement figures on the movement calculator.
  • Marking each tote part from its references: Marking out.
  • Tearout that remains after every remedy, and other planing faults: When it goes wrong.
  • An old plane that still will not cut after sharpening and setup may have a sole or frog problem; a hand-tool restorer or experienced user can look at it.

11. Knowledge check and scenario

Why does a plane flatten a surface when a chisel by itself does not?
The sole rides on the high spots and holds the blade at a fixed depth below them, so the plane cuts only where the wood stands proud. As the high spots go, the cut spreads until the whole face is in one plane.
Your winding sticks sight level, but the straightedge shows light under its middle along the length. What is the board's shape?
Bow, with the hollow on this face. The ends lie in one plane, so there is no twist, but the middle is low. Plane the two ends with short strokes until the straightedge sits evenly, then take full-length passes.
The edge you planed is square to the face at one end and not at the other. What has happened?
The edge has twist along its length, usually from the plane tilting differently at the start and end of each stroke. Mark the high side at the out-of-square end and plane it there until the square sits evenly at both ends and the middle.
Why gauge the thickness from the face side rather than measure it with a rule?
The gauge carries one setting to every part and every edge without numbers, and it works from the reference face, so parts that meet are the same thickness where they meet. Jansa's article describes the gauge as transferring a measurement without numbers.
(Go deeper) What does a steeper cutting angle do in difficult grain, and how do makers get one?
It makes the blade scrape more and lift fibers less. Lie-Nielsen offers 50 and 55 degree frogs for bevel-down planes and suggests honing a bevel-up plane's blade at 45 to 50 degrees; a back bevel does the same on a bevel-down blade.
Imani is flattening a cherry side, and one end of the face keeps tearing out in small chips while the other end planes clean. What should she do first?
A deeper cut lifts bigger chips against the grain and takes the tearout deeper. It also costs thickness she may need.
The grain probably reverses partway along this board, so each end planes cleanly in a different direction. The remedies go cheapest first; a sharper blade and a closer chipbreaker come next.
Sanding can remove shallow tearout on a face that will not be a reference, but it makes fine dust and can round the surface. On a face side, plane it clean.

Checklist

Records your learning only; it is not a qualification.