When it goes wrong
Symptoms from sawing, planing, chopping, fitting and finishing, with the likely causes, what to check and the fix, each linked to the chapter that explains it.
Find the row by what you see, not by what you think went wrong. Check the causes in the order given: the first is the commonest or the cheapest to test. Each fix names its source; where none of our sources covers a fix, the row says so. Write what happened and what you changed in the practice log, so a pattern shows over several attempts.
| What you see | Likely causes | What to check | The fix, and whose | Chapter |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The saw wanders off the line | Pressing down or steering the saw; the eye not over the blade; a bent plate; teeth set more on one side than the other | Sight down the plate for a bend or kink. Make a test cut on scrap with light pressure: if it still drifts the same way every time, suspect the saw | Start in a knife wall on the waste side and let the saw's weight do the work (Paul Sellers, Margins in Cuts). A slight bend may come out or may not matter; a bad kink is not worth fixing, one saw dealer says (Fine Woodworking, Buyer's Guide to Antique Handsaws). A ryoba's blade is replaceable (Woodcraft, Japanese Saw Guide) | Sawing to a line |
| The cut is not square | The square itself; the line not squared round the board; the saw leaning to one side | Run the flip test on the square. Check that the knife line meets itself round all four faces | Test the square by drawing, flipping and drawing again; the gap is twice the error (Popular Woodworking, All About Try Squares). Knife the line round the board and start in the knife wall (Popular Woodworking, Marking Knives). True a slightly out-of-square end on a shooting board, which takes off 1/32 in or less (Popular Woodworking, What's a Shooting Board) | Marking out, Sawing to a line |
| The saw binds | A kinked plate; the kerf closing behind the saw as the board releases tension; a saw with too little set for damp wood | Sight the plate. Watch whether the kerf narrows behind the blade as the cut goes on | A bad kink makes a saw bind (Fine Woodworking, Buyer's Guide to Antique Handsaws). A thin wedge in the kerf behind the saw keeps a closing cut open (our practice, unsourced) Preference | Sawing to a line |
| Tearout: torn hollows in a planed surface | Planing against the grain; a dull blade; too deep a cut; the chipbreaker set far back | Read the grain on the board's edge; plane a short stroke from the other end and compare | Plane with the grain; fibers can run at an angle that the face pattern hides, and splitting a scrap shows the true direction (Popular Woodworking, Reading Grain Direction). Hone the blade, take a finer cut, and set the chipbreaker closer than the general 1/16 in for the finest work (Lie-Nielsen, Bench Planes) | Planing a board square |
| The plane chatters or will not cut | The blade not projecting, or projecting too far; the lever cap too loose; a dull edge | Sight down the sole from the front for the blade. Check the lever cap tension | Set the depth by sighting or by running a scrap past both corners (Lee Valley, Setting the Blade). Lever cap tension just enough to hold the blade while still letting it adjust (Fine Woodworking, Handplaning 101). If the edge is dull, see the row below | Planing a board square |
| The shaving is thick on one side | The blade is not parallel to the sole | Run a scrap past each corner of the mouth and compare the shavings | Move the lateral adjuster until both corner shavings match (Lee Valley, Setting the Blade) | Planing a board square |
| The board rocks after planing | Twist: the face is in two planes. Or a hump in the middle | Sight across a pair of winding sticks laid at each end. Lay a straightedge along, across and on both diagonals | Aligned top edges on winding sticks mean the ends are in one plane; plane the high corners until they align (Fine Woodworking, Use Winding Sticks). A badly twisted board may not yield the thickness you need; choose another rather than plane it thin | Planing a board square |
| The edge crushes or skids instead of cutting (chisel or plane) | A dull edge; a burr left on the back; the back never flattened at the edge | Look at the edge under a light: a dull edge shows a bright line. Feel the back for a burr. Pare the end of a pine board | Flatten the back first: the whole back of a chisel, the first half inch or so of a plane blade (Lee Valley, How to Sharpen). Hone until a burr forms along the whole edge, then remove it on the back (Lie-Nielsen, Sharpening Instructions). A sharp edge pares a thin, unbroken shaving from pine end grain | Sharpening |
| The edge chips | An edge honed too fine or at too low an angle for mallet work; levering waste with a bevel-edge chisel; a knot or grit in the wood | Which chisel, and how it was used: struck, pared or levered | Fine Woodworking's Asa Christiana hones chisels struck with a mallet at a higher angle than paring chisels (How to Use a Honing Guide); finer edges are more fragile (Lee Valley, How to Sharpen). A bevel-edge chisel is "not designed for heavy chopping" (Popular Woodworking, Your Basic Guide to Chisels). Grind past the chip, then hone | Sharpening |
| The housing is loose | The housing laid out from a measurement instead of from the part; sawing on the wrong side of a knife line; paring the walls | Lay the part in the housing and look at which wall the gap is on | Mark one piece directly from the other (Popular Woodworking, Measure, Mark and Lay Out): knife both walls with the divider itself held in place, and saw on the waste side of each. No source we found covers repairing a loose housing; on a practice piece, cut the next one | Housings and rabbets |
| The tenon is loose | Cheeks sawn inside the gauge lines; too much pared off while fitting; a mortise levered wider | Which faces are loose: the cheeks, or the edges | Set the gauge to the chisel that cuts the mortise and mark both parts from it (Mortise and tenon); saw to the waste side of the lines and pare to fit, a little at a time. A through tenon can be wedged, with kerfs across the grain of the mortised piece (Woodcraft, Avoiding Splits with Wedged Tenons); no source we found presents wedging as a repair for a loose fit | Mortise and tenon |
| Dovetail gaps at the baseline | Chopping short of the baseline or past it; a doubled gauge line; the baseline set at less than the stock's thickness | Look at whether the gap is on the face, the inside, or both | Gauge the baseline in one hard pass, slightly over the stock's thickness; double lines cause problems (Popular Woodworking, Hand-Cutting Dovetails). Chop from both faces to the line. No fetched source covers filling a gap; the next joint is the fix | Dovetails |
| Dovetail gaps along a tail | Sawing on the line or inside it on the pin board; the tail board moving while the pins were knifed | Look at the knife line on the pin board: is it still there beside the gap? | Transfer with a thin knife and saw the pins on the waste side; rub soft pencil on the tails to find tight spots (Popular Woodworking, Hand-Cutting Dovetails). Sellers saws to the line and does not pare afterwards (Margins in Cuts). No fetched source covers filling the gap | Dovetails |
| Dovetail gaps at a corner | A half pin sawn off the line; the ends not square before layout; the board not flat | Square the ends of both boards and check them on a flat surface | Square the ends on a shooting board before layout (Popular Woodworking, Hand-Cutting Dovetails). No fetched source covers filling the gap | Dovetails |
| The glue-up racks | Clamps set off the line of the joints; too much pressure; no dry fit | Measure both diagonals while the glue is wet: equal diagonals mean square | Clamp with enough pressure to bring the joints tightly together, not more (Titebond, Titebond Original); too much pressure starves a joint of glue (Forest Products Laboratory, Wood Adhesives). Move a clamp to pull the long diagonal in, and dry-fit first next time | Glue, finish and mending |
| The finish stays tacky | Excess oil left on the surface; a cool or damp room; coats too thick | Wipe a hidden spot with a clean rag: oil on the rag means excess on the surface | For Watco Danish Oil, "Removal of all excess material is essential" to proper drying, and the maker says to apply it at 60 to 90 F (Rust-Oleum, Watco Danish Oil TDS, Jan. 2026). Cool, humid rooms add 8 to 10 hours to dry time, General Finishes says (Dry Time and Cure Time). Follow your product's label | Glue, finish and mending, Finishes for a small piece |
| The board cups after cutting | A flatsawn board taking up or losing moisture faster on one face; a board not settled to the room; tension released by the cut | Read the end grain: rings arching across the end mean flatsawn. Leave it flat overnight and look again | Flatsawn boards are the most likely to cup (Popular Woodworking, Using Grain Pattern to Choose Lumber). Store boards flat and stickered in the room you will work in, and rough-cut parts oversize, about 1 in long and 1/4 in wide, before final sizing (Popular Woodworking, Why Wood Warps). A single board exposed on its own changes faster than a stack (Purdue, FNR-403-W) | Choosing wood |
How to read this table
- Most faults have more than one cause. Change one thing at a time, and test it on scrap before the real part.
- A tool problem is not a skill problem. A kinked saw or a blade that will not hold an edge does not get better with practice. Buying or inheriting used tools says what to check on a saw, a plane and a chisel.
- Gaps in a joint tell you which cut caused them. Note the cause in the practice log; the dovetail rows give no hidden fix, because none of our fetched sources does.
This table finds likely causes; it cannot see your tool or your board. It does not say whether a flawed joint is strong enough for what the piece will carry. A loose or cracked handle or a mushroomed chisel head is a safety question before it is a quality one: OSHA's hand tool guide names each as a hazard in workplace use (Hand and Power Tools). Repair or replace the tool before using it.