Which joint where
Reference

Which joint where

The joints a small box or tote uses and the ones it does not, with what each resists, the tools it needs and the depth or proportion convention behind it. Filter by the kit you have.

Every depth and proportion in this table is a convention from a named publisher, not an engineering rating, and the row says whose it is. Where two publishers differ, the row gives both. The tote uses four of these joints: rabbets or through dovetails at the corners, a housing for the divider, a through tenon for the handle, and a nailed bottom.

JointWhat it resistsWhere it goesToolsDepth or proportion convention, and whoseDifficultyChapter
Butt joint, nailedLittle on its own: the nails hold it. It lets a part move across its width if the nails allowThe tote's bottom, nailed under the box with its grain along the length so it can swell and shrink across its widthSaw, square, hammer, nails (a drill for pilot holes in hardwood)No depth. Purdue Extension's furniture bulletin says to design so wood is free to move across the grain (FNR-163) Physical principleEasiestGlue, finish and mending
RabbetLocates one part in the step of another and adds glue surface; glued and nailed, it resists the corner pulling apartThe tote's corners on the simpler path: the sides' ends rabbeted, the ends sitting in themSaw, chisel, marking gauge, knife; a rabbet plane is optionalAbout one-third of the stock's thickness: in 3/4 in stock at least 1/4 in, never more than 1/2 in (Fine Woodworking, All About Rabbet and Dado Joints) ConventionEasyHousings and rabbets
Housing (dado)Holds a shelf or divider square and stops it sliding up or down; resists the divider rackingThe tote's divider, in the pair of walls it meets. A housing runs across the grain of the wall it is in. Where a wall's grain runs up and down (Noor's rabbeted ends, in the fictional cases), the same cut runs with the grain and is strictly a grooveSaw, chisel, marking gauge, knife; a router plane is optionalOne-third of the stock's thickness, "and never more than half" (Fine Woodworking, same article). In 3/4 in stock, 1/4 in deep ConventionEasyHousings and rabbets
Stopped housingAs a housing, with the joint hidden at the frontA shelf or divider whose front edge should not show the grooveAs a housing, plus a chisel to clear the stopped endStops short of the front edge by the thickness of the material (Fine Woodworking, same article). Common Woodworking teaches it as a free step-by-step project (Common Woodworking) ConventionModerateHousings and rabbets (named)
Mortise and tenonRacking, bending and twisting: the shoulders resist bending and twisting, one Fine Woodworking author writesFrames, legs and rails, and any part that meets another end-onSaw, chisel near the tenon's thickness, mallet, marking gauge, knifeTenon one-third of the thickness of the stock being mortised (1/4 in in 3/4 in stock); some modern texts say half, which the author ties to machine work; at least five times its thickness long; about half the rail's width (Popular Woodworking, Tenons Rule). Garrett Hack makes his "a little more than one-third", and thicker in soft wood (Fine Woodworking, Joining Legs to Aprons) ConventionModerateMortise and tenon
Through tenon, wedged or pinnedAs a mortise and tenon; a wedged through tenon spread into a flared mortise "can't pull apart after the wedges go home", Popular Woodworking's Tom Caspar writes, and a pin draws the joint tight without clampsThe tote's handle, through each endAs a mortise and tenon. Wedged: a saw for the kerfs and scrap for wedges. Pinned: a drill or brace and bit, and a dowel or riven pinThickness by the one-third convention, length set by the stock it passes through. Wedges: saw the kerfs across the grain of the mortised piece, so the wedges push against its end grain (Woodcraft, Avoiding Splits with Wedged Tenons, Ken Burton); taper the mortise's ends about 3 degrees, up to 8 (Popular Woodworking, Wedged Mortise and Tenon, Tom Caspar). Drawbore offset at most 1/16 in (Popular Woodworking, Drawbore with Andy Rawls) ConventionModerateMortise and tenon
Through dovetailPulling apart in one direction, by its shape alone; shows end grain on both facesThe tote's corners on the standard path; boxes and carcasesDovetail or fine saw, chisels, mallet, marking gauge, knife, bevel gauge, dividersSlope 1:6 (about 9 degrees) for softwood and 1:8 (about 7) for hardwood by convention (Popular Woodworking, My Take on Dovetail Angles, Glen D. Huey, who questions the rule). Woodcraft cites Forest Products Laboratory tests that found no strength difference between 7.5 and 17.5 degrees (Proper Angles for Dovetails). Baseline gauged slightly over the stock's thickness (Popular Woodworking, Hand-Cutting Dovetails) ConventionHarderDovetails
Half-blind dovetailAs a through dovetail, with the joint hidden on one faceDrawer frontsAs a through dovetailNot taught here. The English Woodworker's paid spoon rack series teaches it on a drawer (The Spoon Rack); Paul Sellers calls it "extremely difficult" to cut pins first (Tails and Pins)HarderDovetails (named)
Half lapHolds two crossing or meeting parts flush; glue does most of the workFrames and crossing railsSaw, chisel, marking gauge, knifeEach part cut away to half its thickness, which is what the name means. The Hand Tool School covers it as one topic of its Semester 1 (Semester 1); we found no free source with a fuller conventionEasyNot taught here; Housings and rabbets uses the same sawing and paring
MiterHides end grain at a corner; the two angled faces meet with glue and whatever reinforcement the frame usesPicture frames and trimA miter box or shooting board, a fine saw, clampsNot taught here. Learn Art Framing's Frames chapter covers frame cornersModerateLearn Art Framing

How to read this table

  • The kit filters follow The first tools. "Household tools" means a saw, a square and a hammer. "The first kit" means the default kit there: a ryoba, a square, a knife, a marking gauge, dividers, three bevel-edge chisels, a mallet, a smoothing plane, sharpening gear, clamps and glue. "Extra tools" means something outside it, such as a drill for drawbore pins or a miter box.
  • Difficulty is our ranking for a first attempt by hand Preference, ordered by how many surfaces must meet at once. A rabbet has two; a dovetail has a dozen or more.
  • A depth convention is a starting point. In 3/4 in stock the one-third conventions all land on 1/4 in, which is why the tote's housings, rabbets and tenon share one marking gauge setting. The cut list calculator uses those defaults and lets you change them.
  • Grain direction matters as much as depth. Fine Woodworking's rabbet article says the grain of both pieces should run the same way, plywood excepted. Through dovetails need all four walls with the grain running along the wall; rabbeted corners allow ends with the grain running up and down, which lets a narrow board make a tall end.
Limits

This table describes conventions; it does not rate any joint for a load. Whether a box, a shelf or a repaired chair will hold what you put in it or on it depends on the wood, the fit and the glue, and nothing here settles it. For furniture that holds a person's weight, ask a furniture restorer.