Dovetails: laying out, sawing and fitting a through dovetail
Choose a slope, space the tails with dividers, saw the tails and mark the pins from them, chop to the baseline and read what each gap says about the cut.
- Start here: the essentials
- 1. How a through dovetail holds
- 2. Slope, baseline and spacing
- 3. Sawing and chopping the tails
- 4. Marking, sawing and chopping the pins
- 5. Fitting, and reading the gaps
- 6. Pins first, other slopes and other dovetails
- 7. See it
- 8. Practice
- 9. Your setup
- 10. Check your work
- 11. Knowledge check and scenario
Start here Essentials
At minimum: one practice corner from two offcuts, tails first. The tote's corners come after, if your tote is dovetailed.
- Square the ends of two offcuts. Shooting board, or square and pare (Slope, baseline and spacing).
- Gauge the baseline on both pieces. One firm pass, a hair over the other board's thickness (Slope, baseline and spacing).
- Lay out three tails with dividers and a bevel. Walk the dividers from both edges, then draw the slopes (Slope, baseline and spacing).
- Saw and chop the tails, then mark, saw and chop the pins from them. Saw on the waste side of every line (Sawing and chopping the tails, Marking, sawing and chopping the pins).
- Fit the corner and name every gap. Write each one and its likely cause on the practice sheet (Fitting, and reading the gaps).
Minimum time: about two hours for a first practice corner. Done when: the practice corner goes together with hand or light mallet pressure, its faces flush and square, and any gaps are noted on the practice sheet with their cause.
1. How a through dovetail holds Understand
A dovetail joins two boards at a corner with interlocking fingers cut in their ends. The flared fingers on one board are the tails; the fingers on the other board that fit between them are the pins. The narrower part-pins at each edge of the pin board are the half pins. In a through dovetail both sets of fingers run the full thickness of the other board, so end grain shows on both outside faces of the corner.
Physical principle The shape does the holding in one direction. A tail is wider at the end of its board than at its root, so once the joint is together the tail board will not pull away along its own length: the tails are wedged behind the pins. The joint comes apart only the way it went together, by sliding the tail board sideways off the pins, square to its own face. In a closed box the corner at the other end of each wall blocks that sideways slide, and glue does the rest. That is why a dovetailed box stays tight long after a box held only by glue on end grain would have opened.
The same geometry sets a rule about grain. A dovetail is cut into the end of a board, with the fingers running along the grain. If the grain runs across the fingers instead, each finger is a short piece of cross grain that snaps off. So every wall of a dovetailed tote needs its grain running along the wall, horizontally, and that includes the ends. A tote end that stands taller than your board is wide has to come from a wider board. This is the reason Hal (fictional) bought a 1x10 for his ends, and the reason Noor (fictional) kept rabbets: her ends are cut from a 1x8 with the grain running up and down, so a board 7 1/4 in wide makes an end 10 1/2 in tall, and those ends cannot take dovetails. Choosing wood covers reading the grain, and Housings and rabbets covers the rabbeted corner.
| Word | What it means here |
|---|---|
| Tail board | The board with the flared fingers (the tails) cut in its end. |
| Pin board | The board whose fingers (the pins) fill the spaces between the tails. |
| Baseline | The gauged line across both faces of each board, one board's thickness from its end. Every saw cut stops at it and every chisel cut finishes in it. |
| Slope | The angle of the tails' sides, given as a ratio such as 1:7 (one unit across for every seven along). |
| Waste | The wood between fingers that is removed. Mark it with a scribble so the saw goes on the right side of every line. |
| Cheek | The sawn side of a tail or a pin, the surface that meets its neighbor in the finished joint. |
Which board gets the tails is a choice in a box with four dovetailed corners. Hal puts the tails on his sides and the pins on his ends, so the dovetailed part of each end is the lower 7 1/4 in, where the sides meet it, and the top of the end rises above the sides to carry the handle.
2. Slope, baseline and spacing
Square ends first
Every line in a dovetail is measured from the end of the board, so the end has to be square to the faces and the edges before you mark anything. A Popular Woodworking method article squares the ends on a shooting board as its first step (Hand-Cutting Dovetails). Planing a board square covers the shooting board. Mark the face side and face edge on both boards as Marking out describes; the outside faces of the box are the reference faces, and every square and gauge registers from them.
The baseline
Set a marking gauge to the thickness of the other board and gauge a line all the way round each board's end: both faces and both edges. The same article sets the gauge slightly over the stock's thickness and marks in one hard pass, because a second pass can leave two lines and you will not know which one to cut to. Frank Klausz, in a Woodcraft excerpt of his method, sets the gauge to the thickness plus 1/32 in (Hand Cut Through Dovetails). Convention The extra leaves the tails and pins standing a hair proud of the faces, and you plane them flush after the glue dries. A knife wall is the small vertical wall a knife or gauge cut leaves in the fibers; a chisel set in it registers against it, which is what makes the baseline crisp.
Choosing a slope
| Slope | About | Who uses it |
|---|---|---|
| 1:6 | 9 1/2 degrees | The convention for softwoods |
| 1:7 | 8 degrees | A middle value; Hal's choice for yellow-poplar |
| 1:8 | 7 degrees | The convention for hardwoods; Imani's (fictional) choice for cherry |
Convention The usual rule is 1:6 for softwood and 1:8 for hardwood, and Glen Huey at Popular Woodworking gives both and then questions the rule (My Take on Dovetail Angles). A Woodcraft Magazine answer reports Forest Products Laboratory tests of dovetails from 7.5 to 17.5 degrees that found no difference in joint strength, and advises choosing by eye (Proper Angles for Dovetails). We have not read the test itself. Our default is 1:7, or whatever you like the look of, between 1:6 and 1:8. Set it once on a bevel gauge (a sliding bevel: a blade that locks at any angle in a stock) by laying the blade across a board marked 1 in across and 7 in along, then lock it and leave it locked for the whole tote.
Spacing with dividers
Dividers are a pair of hinged steel legs with sharp points. They hold a distance and repeat it, so the spacing comes from the board rather than from arithmetic. George Walker describes stepping off repeated elements such as dovetails with them, and warns that accuracy falls off when the legs open much beyond about 45 degrees: use more, smaller steps instead (Essential Dividers). Check that both points are the same length before you start.
Rob Cosman's no-math method, from a Woodcraft article (Demystifying Hand-Cut Dovetails), works like this on the tail board, along its end:
- Mark the half pins. Make a mark in from each edge for the half pin. Cosman uses about 1/4 in on a 5 1/2 in board; Hal uses 1/4 in on 7 1/4 in.
- Set the dividers to one tail plus one pin. Guess at first. The guess does not matter, because the next step corrects it.
- Walk from one half-pin mark. Step once per tail. Adjust the dividers until the last step lands one pin's width past the half-pin mark on the far edge. Cosman's pins are thin, so for him that is about 1/8 in.
- Walk from both ends. Prick a mark at every step from the left half-pin mark, then every step from the right. The left walk marks one side of every tail and the right walk marks the other side. The gaps between them are the pins.
- Draw the slopes. From each mark, draw a line with the bevel gauge from the end down to the baseline, flaring so each tail is widest at the end. Square the lines across the end grain, and scribble the waste.
If you would rather see numbers, the dovetail calculator takes the board width, the slope, the number of tails, the half pin and the pin width, and returns the tail width at the wide end and the dividers' spread. For Hal's 7 1/4 in sides with four tails at 1:7, 1/4 in half pins and 3/8 in pins, it gives tails about 1 13/32 in at the wide end and a spread of about 1 25/32 in. Even spacing is a convention, not a requirement: Klausz's excerpt says plainly that tails need not be evenly spaced.
Pencil or knife. Knife lines give the most precise fit and a wall to register a chisel in (Paul Sellers, Knifewalls). In pine, Sellers lays out in pencil instead, because pine compresses, and he finds a joint cut exactly to knife lines in pine too tight to go together (Understanding Softwood Dovetails). Preference In a soft, unknown "common board" pine, a sharp pencil line is a reasonable first choice; in poplar and cherry, a knife.
3. Sawing and chopping the tails
Hold the tail board upright with its end a few inches above the table, clamped to the table's edge or to a leg as A shop on a table shows. Tilt your head, not the saw: the cut runs at the slope across the face but straight down, square to the face, through the thickness.
- Saw one side of every tail, then the other. The Popular Woodworking article works in that order: all the cuts that lean one way, then all that lean the other. Your arm repeats the same angle, so the cuts match each other.
- Saw on the waste side, just touching the line. The line stays on the tail. Start the cut at the far corner, with the saw nearly flat on the end grain, then bring it down to follow the line on the face nearest you.
- Stop at the baseline on both faces. Watch both faces. A saw that runs past the baseline on the outside face leaves a kerf that shows for the life of the box. The kerf is the slot the saw leaves, as wide as the saw's set teeth.
- Saw off the half-pin waste. Crosscut down the baseline from the edge to remove each corner piece.
- Chop the waste between the tails. With a chisel a little narrower than the gap, chop from one face halfway through, then turn the board over and chop from the other face. Start the first cuts about 1/32 in into the waste, as Klausz does, and take the last cut with the chisel's flat face in the baseline. A chisel set straight into the line on the first blow gets pushed back past it by its own bevel.
Paul Sellers saws to the line and does not pare the tails afterwards: the sawn tails become the template for the pins, and leaving extra to trim works against you (Margins in Cuts for Hand Work). Preference Whether you pare a tail that is off the line is your call, but pare only to make the cheek flat and square to the face, not to chase a prettier angle. The pins are marked from what you have, so a slightly crooked tail still makes a tight joint.
For a saw that drifts off the line, Sawing to a line has the causes. A ryoba's pull stroke and a Western dovetail saw's push stroke both work here; the starting cut on the far corner is the same.
4. Marking, sawing and chopping the pins
The pins are not laid out with dividers or a bevel. They are traced from the tails, so any small difference in the tails is copied exactly into the pins. That is the reason for cutting tails first: the hard part is done once.
- Stand the pin board on end, its outside face away from you. Clamp it upright to the table edge, its end level with a block or a stack of boards of the same height that will carry the tail board flat.
- Lay the tail board on its end. Its baseline sits exactly on the pin board's inside face, its edges flush with the pin board's edges, its outside face up. Clamp or hold it so it cannot shift.
- Trace the tails with a thin knife. The Popular Woodworking article uses a thin knife for this, so the point reaches into the corner of each tail. Press the flat of the blade against the tail's cheek and draw it toward you, lightly first and then firmly.
- Square the lines down both faces to the baseline. Use the square from the end grain marks. Scribble the waste: on the pin board the waste is the space where each tail will sit.
- Saw on the waste side of every line. The knife line stays on the pin. Here the saw cut is straight across the end and slopes through the thickness, so the saw follows the end grain line and stays square to the face down to the baseline.
- Chop out the sockets. Halfway from each face, the same as the tails, the last cut in the baseline.
Left-handed. Imani (fictional) mirrors the holding: she clamps the board at the left end of the shared bench and stands to its right, so her saw hand is on the open side. The order of cuts and the lines do not change.
5. Fitting, and reading the gaps
Start the joint by hand. Push the tail board onto the pins until it stops, then look. A joint that is tight at one spot shows it: the Popular Woodworking article rubs a soft pencil on the tails, pushes the joint partway, and looks for the pencil marks left on the pins. Pare only where the marks are, a shaving at a time. Paring is cutting with a chisel pushed by hand rather than struck, taking off a thin slice.
Then tap it home with a mallet over a block of scrap held across the whole joint rather than on one tail. Test it If it needs more than light blows, stop: a dovetail driven too tight splits the tail board along the grain, and that crack is in the wood for good. Take it apart by tapping the tail board back off, square to its face, and find the tight spot. Fit each corner of the tote dry, then take it apart for gluing, and number each joint so the same tails go back into the same pins.
Gaps will happen in the first few joints. Each one is evidence about a particular cut. The table is our reading of the method's steps: each gap is matched to the step that, done carefully, prevents it.
| What you see | Likely cause | Next time |
|---|---|---|
| A gap at the baseline, between a tail's root and the face of the pin board | Waste chopped short of the baseline, or chopped past it on the outside face so the line is crushed back; a saw cut stopped short of the baseline | Start chopping in the waste and finish in the line; saw all the way to the baseline on both faces |
| A gap along one side of a tail, the full depth | The tail board shifted while you traced it, or the pin was sawn on the wrong side of the line | Clamp the tail board for tracing; scribble the waste before every cut |
| A gap along a tail on one face only | The saw leaned through the thickness, so the cheek is not square to the face | Watch both faces as you saw; see Sawing to a line |
| A gap at a half pin, at the edge | The end was not square, or the boards' edges were not flush when you traced | Square the ends on the shooting board; align the edges before tracing |
| The corner is not square, or the faces are not flush | Baselines gauged from different faces; ends not square; the gauge reset between boards | Gauge every part from its reference face with one setting |
| A split in the tail board | The joint was driven too tight | Fit with the pencil test and pare before driving it home |
Write each gap and its cause on the practice sheet (it has rows for gaps at the baseline, along a tail and at a corner). When it goes wrong repeats this table with the other faults in the manual.
This chapter tells you what caused a gap. It does not teach a way to fill or hide one: no source we could read covers that beyond forum posts, so we have nothing to stand behind. A gap in a tote corner is a cosmetic matter for you to judge. Whether a joint is strong enough for a particular load is not something a fit test, or this manual, settles. The next joint, with the cause fixed, is the remedy we can offer.
Go deeper 6. Pins first, other slopes and other dovetails
Pins first
Some makers cut the pins first and mark the tails from them. Frank Klausz does, and his excerpt has him sawing the pins' angles by eye, "somewhere between 8 and 12 degrees", with the saw held vertical, then tracing the tails from the pins. Paul Sellers explains why he cuts tails first: with a Western saw pushed from the outside, the outer fibers of the show face stay supported, so the visible corners stay crisp; marking tails from pins means cutting from the inside toward the outside face. He says every craftsman who trained him cut tails first, that he cuts pins first only in repairs, and that the other method works for some people (Tails and Pins: Which Is Best?). The Popular Woodworking article also cuts tails first. Both orders make the same joint; we teach one so the steps are the same every time.
Slopes compared
Huey's dissent from the softwood and hardwood rule is practical: drawers commonly have a hardwood front and pine or poplar sides, so which wood decides the slope? He adds that router jigs commonly cut at 14 degrees and that he prefers a steeper slope because he likes the look. The Woodcraft answer notes that antique furniture shows slopes from about 7 to 14 degrees (up to 1:4). Taken together, the slope is a matter of appearance within a wide range, and the 1:6 and 1:8 figures are a tradition rather than a measured optimum.
Half-blind dovetails, and a marker
A half-blind dovetail stops short of the pin board's outside face, so the end grain shows on one face only. It is the joint at the front of a traditional drawer. It is chopped rather than sawn through and is not part of the tote, so we name it and leave it there. A dovetail marker is a small shop-made guide with the slope cut on it, used in place of a bevel gauge; one paid school includes making one as an exercise in its first semester (The Hand Tool School, Semester 1). A scrap of hardwood with a 1:7 line sawn and planed true, glued to a fence, does the same job as the bevel gauge and cannot drift.
7. See it See it
Hal's garden tote corners. Hal (fictional) is 71 and works in his unheated attached garage. His sides are yellow-poplar 1x8, 18 in long and 7 1/4 in high; his ends are cut from a 1x10, 10 3/4 in wide by 9 1/4 in tall with the grain running across, because dovetailed ends need horizontal grain and stand taller than a 1x8 is wide. He chooses 1:7, four tails on each 7 1/4 in corner, 1/4 in half pins and 3/8 in pins. The dovetail calculator gives tails about 1 13/32 in at the wide end and a dividers' spread of about 1 25/32 in. He sets the dividers to that, walks the end of a side from the left half-pin mark, and the fourth step lands 3/8 in past the right half-pin mark, as the method says it should. Then he cuts a practice corner from two 1x8 offcuts before touching the tote.
Known: the board sizes, the slope he chose, the spacing, and that his inherited 26 in handsaw is too coarse for this work, so the dovetails are sawn with the ryoba. Assumed: that his yellow-poplar was dry and settled when he cut it; he let it sit indoors for a week. Open: whether his practice corner's gaps come from the chisel or the saw, which the practice corner itself settles: two gaps along tails on the inside face only, so the saw leaned through the thickness. He writes it on the practice sheet and cuts the next corner watching both faces.
- Hand-Cutting Dovetails, Popular Woodworking (Logan Wittmer, 2024): the tails-first sequence with photographs, from squaring the ends to the pencil test.
- Demystifying Hand-Cut Dovetails, Woodcraft (Rob Cosman): the dividers method of spacing, step by step.
- Hand Cut Through Dovetails, Woodcraft (Frank Klausz's method): pins first, sawn by eye, for comparison.
- Understanding Softwood Dovetails, Paul Sellers: why a pine joint wants a pencil line and a little compression.
8. Practice Practice
Minimum: one practice corner with three tails, cut from two offcuts of the same thickness, fitted and its gaps written on the practice sheet. Time: about two hours for the first corner; a tote's four corners take an afternoon each for most people at first. Materials: two offcuts at least as wide as your tote's sides and about 8 in long, the saw, a marking gauge, a knife or sharp pencil, a square, dividers, a bevel gauge, chisels of about 1/4 and 1/2 in, a mallet, two clamps and a soft pencil.
- Square and mark. Square both ends, mark the reference faces and gauge the baselines round both pieces in one pass each.
- Lay out three tails. Use the dividers method or the dovetail calculator, then the bevel gauge. Scribble the waste.
- Saw and chop the tails. One side of every tail, then the other; chop halfway from each face.
- Trace, saw and chop the pins. Thin knife, square down, saw on the waste side, chop.
- Fit and record. Pencil test, pare, tap home over a block. Write every gap and its cause on the practice sheet.
- Cut a second corner at a different slope (Go deeper; optional). Try 1:6 if the first was 1:8, and decide which you like the look of.
9. Your setup Your setup
10. Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- Did the joint go together with hand pressure or light mallet blows over a block, without a split?
- Are the outside faces flush, or proud by the same hair everywhere so a plane will bring them flush?
- Is the corner square when you check it with the square on the inside?
- Did every saw cut stop at the baseline on the show faces, with no kerf running past it?
- Is every gap written down with a cause, not just noticed?
- On the tote, does every wall have its grain running along the wall?
Worked example
Imani (fictional) cuts her first cherry corner at 1:8 with three tails on a 6 in side. It goes together with three light taps. Two faces are flush; on the inside of the pin board she finds a thin gap at the baseline under the middle tail. Looking at the socket, she sees the baseline crushed back by about 1/32 in where she set the chisel straight in the line on the first blow. She writes "gap at the baseline, middle socket, chisel started in the line" on the practice sheet and starts the next corner's chopping in the waste. The corner passes every other criterion, and she keeps it as a test piece for her finish.
Common mistakes
- Cutting on the wrong side of a line. Notice it by scribbling every piece of waste before the saw comes out.
- Sawing past the baseline on the show face. Notice it by watching both faces on every cut, not only the face nearest you.
- Moving the bevel gauge or the marking gauge partway through. Notice it when the tails of one corner do not match the next. Set each tool once and leave it.
- Driving a tight joint home. Notice it when the mallet blows stop moving the joint. Stop there, take it apart and pencil-test it.
- Dovetailing an end with vertical grain. Notice it before you cut: the fingers would run across the grain and break off.
What is still unresolved
- How to get the corners glued while the glue is still workable, and how to check the box for square: Glue, finish and mending.
- The divider's housings and the handle's tenons, which go into the same glue-up: Housings and rabbets and Mortise and tenon.
- Whether a gap is acceptable on your tote is your judgment; whether a joint will carry a particular load is not something this manual settles.