Measuring without numbers: story sticks, dividers and sizing from the thing itself
Lay the things a piece will hold against a story stick, set proportions with dividers, and bring in numbers only where buying wood or a calculator needs them.
Start here Essentials
At minimum, this chapter asks you to put the things your tote will carry on the table, carry their sizes onto one strip of wood, and turn those marks into a parts list. Everything marked Go deeper is optional on a first pass.
- Gather the things the tote will carry, and find the space it must fit. Put them on the table; note the shelf or cabinet it lives in (Start from the contents).
- Mark the longest, widest and tallest onto a story stick. One strip of light wood, one pencil mark and a note per size (The story stick).
- Add clearance and mark the inside sizes. Then add the wall thicknesses with an offcut of the board itself (From inside sizes to parts).
- Choose the side and handle heights. Use dividers and a cardboard mock-up, and check the handle against what stands under it (Dividers and proportion).
- Write the parts on the tote sheet. Read numbers off the stick only now (When numbers come in).
Minimum time: about an hour and a half. Done when: a story stick carries every tote size, and the parts list on the Tote project sheet is filled in.
1. A measurement is a relationship Understand
A measurement is not a number. It is a relationship between two things: this bottle and the space beside it, this end and the side it meets, this tote and the cabinet it slides into. A number is one way to carry that relationship from one place to another. It is not the only way, and on a small piece it is often the worst way.
Every time a size is turned into a number and back again, there is a chance to get it wrong. You read the tape, you remember or write the figure, you do the sum, you read the tape again at the board. Christopher Schwarz, writing in Popular Woodworking, names the usual failures: transposed figures and the "burned" inch, when you start at the 1 in mark on a tape for accuracy and forget to take the inch off (For dividers I fall). His answer is to skip the arithmetic where you can.
The fewer translations between two things, the fewer errors. The most direct transfer of all is to mark one piece from another: hold the end against the side and mark the side where the end stops. Robert Lang's Popular Woodworking article on measuring and layout recommends exactly that, and a story stick for the sizes you cannot transfer directly (Measure, mark and lay out). Preference
This chapter is the idea the manual is built around. The tote is not built to someone else's drawing. It is sized from the things it will carry and the place it will live, and those sizes travel from the things to the wood on a story stick and a pair of dividers. Numbers come in where they earn their place: buying boards, the cut list calculator, and the movement and dovetail figures. Other projects use the same method; a tote just makes it easy to see.
| Way to carry a size | Translations | Where it fits |
|---|---|---|
| Mark one piece directly from another | None | Fitting parts that touch: an end against a side, a tenon against its mortise |
| Story stick | One: thing to stick, stick to wood | Sizes taken from things that are not wood, and sizes used on several parts |
| Dividers | One: a span held in the points | Equal spaces, and a part in proportion to another |
| Tape or rule and a number | Three or more: read, write, sum, read again | Buying wood, a calculator, telling someone else a size |
2. The story stick
A story stick is a strip of wood that carries every key size of a project as a pencil mark with a short note beside it. Woodcraft's guide describes sticks that nearly eliminate the tape in cabinet layout, each location a pencil mark with a small note, and says they record the relationships between parts better than a tape does (Story stick, Woodcraft). Woodcraft suggests a light-colored strip 1 1/2 to 2 in wide so the marks show. Convention
Making one for a tote
- Material. A straight strip of pale wood a little longer than the tallest or longest thing you will mark, and longer than the space the tote must fit. A rip from the edge of your tote board works, as does a paint stirrer for a small tote or a strip of thin plywood. It needs one straight edge and one square end.
- The square end is zero. Every mark is measured from that end. Mark it with an arrow and do not trim it.
- One face per direction. Write "length" on one face, "width" on one edge or the other face, and "height" on another. Marks for different directions on the same face are how mistakes happen.
- A mark and a note. A short line square across the stick in sharp pencil, and beside it what it is: "cloths box", "+ clearance", "inside length". A letter for each item, matching the contents list on the tote sheet, keeps the notes short.
- Pencil, sharp. Lang points out that a thick pencil line can be wider than the tolerance you are working to and recommends a 0.5 mm pencil or a knife. Pencil can be erased when you change your mind; a knife cannot.
Marking a thing onto the stick
- Stand the stick against a flat surface, zero end down on the table or butted against a wall, block or book.
- Set the thing against the stick in the position it will sit in the tote. A bottle stands up; the cloths box stands on whichever edge you plan.
- Lay a straightedge or small square across the top of the thing so it reaches the stick, and mark where it touches. Sighting by eye alone is less accurate than a square across.
- Write the note before you pick up the next thing.
Clearance without a number
Things need room to go in and come out. How much is your choice. A pencil width, the thickness of a coin or a scrap of thin card are all clearances you can add to the stick without reading anything: set the spacer against the mark and mark again. For a tote that holds things you lift out every day, more room is easier to use and wastes space; less room holds things still and makes them harder to grab. Preference
If you want a particular clearance, such as 1/4 in, read it from a rule once onto a small scrap and keep that scrap as your clearance block. Every clearance after that is added with the block, not with a number.
The board itself is a measuring tool. Wall thickness, divider thickness and bottom thickness are the thickness of the board you bought. Lay an offcut of it on the stick at the mark and mark its far side. That carries 3/4 in, or 13/16 in, or whatever the board really is, without reading a rule.
3. Start from the contents
Put everything the tote will carry on the table, and go to the place it will live. Every size the tote has comes from these two.
- The things. Arrange them as they will sit: standing or lying, in what rows, which ones together. Try two or three arrangements. The arrangement decides the tote far more than any number does.
- The space. A shelf, a cabinet, a car boot, the gap beside a door. Mark its clear height and width on the stick. A cabinet under a sink often has a drain trap that lowers the clear height in the middle; mark the lowest point.
- The hand. You carry the tote by its handle, so there must be room for fingers between the handle and whatever stands beside or under it.
The parts of the tote
Every tote in this manual has the same seven parts: two ends, two sides, one divider, one handle and a bottom. The handle runs the length of the tote and is tenoned through the ends. The ends are the tall parts that carry the handle; the sides are the long walls between them. The corners are rabbets (the simpler path) or through dovetails (the standard). The divider splits the inside into two compartments. The bottom is nailed under the box.
Three rules the layout has to follow
The divider runs whichever way the contents need. It sits in slots in the pair of walls it meets. A divider that runs the length of the tote sits in the ends; one that runs across the width sits in the sides. All three fictional totes in this manual run it the length, and the cut list calculator offers both. A housing (or dado) is a slot cut across the grain of the wall it is in. In an end whose grain runs up and down, the same slot runs with the grain and is strictly a groove; it is cut with the same saw and chisel. Housings and rabbets cuts both.
Nothing under the handle is taller than the handle's underside. The handle runs over a lengthwise divider, so tall things stand beside the handle, in a compartment, and not under it. The story stick check is simple: mark the handle's underside on the height face, and every item that will sit under the handle must mark below it. Then check that a hand fits between the handle and the things beside it.
The grain of the ends follows the corner joint. Through dovetails need all four walls with their grain running horizontally, along the wall. So a dovetailed tote's ends must be cut from a board as wide as the end is tall. On the rabbet path the ends may have their grain running up and down, which lets a narrow board make a tall end. Mark the end grain direction on the stick's notes, because it decides which board the ends come from. Grain explains why grain direction matters, and Dovetails takes up the dovetailed corner.
From inside sizes to parts
Work from the inside out. The contents and the clearance give the inside sizes; the board's thickness and the joints turn them into part sizes. On the stick:
- Inside length. Mark the longest arrangement of things in a compartment, add the clearance block, and mark "inside length". Check every compartment fits under that mark.
- Inside width. Mark compartment A's width plus clearance, then an offcut for the divider, then compartment B's width plus clearance. The last mark is "inside width".
- Height. Mark the tallest item, the handle's underside and top, the end's height, and the bottom's thickness. Then check the whole tote, with the bottom, against the space's clear height.
- Parts. Each part's length is an inside size plus whatever the joints add, added with offcuts. A side runs past the inside length by the thickness of an end at each end. An end on the rabbet path is the inside width plus the rabbet depth at each side. A divider in slots is the inside length plus the slot depth at each end. The cut list calculator does the same steps with numbers, which makes it a check on the stick.
The tote's size is your design. This chapter gives a method for sizing it, not a right size or a right proportion, and the ratios below are a design aid, not a rule. It does not rate a load. A tote meant to carry heavy things, such as tools or full jars, should be sized for you to lift, and whether a handle, joint or bottom will carry a given weight is not something the stick or the calculator settles; a test with the real load, or a furniture maker's advice, does.
4. Dividers and proportion
Dividers are a pair of hinged legs with sharp points, like a drawing compass with two points. They hold a span exactly and carry it anywhere, and they do two jobs a story stick does not: they divide a length into equal parts, and they relate one part to another.
Stepping off equal spaces
To split a length into equal parts, open the dividers to a guess, put one point at the start, and walk the dividers along the line, swinging them point over point. If the last step overshoots the end, close them a little; if it falls short, open them; walk again. George Walker's Popular Woodworking column says accuracy falls off when the points are opened much beyond about 45 degrees, and advises doubling the number of steps instead, eight steps rather than four (Essential dividers). Convention He also says to check that the two points are the same length, and to touch them up on sandpaper or a stone. Schwarz uses dividers to split a face into five equal spaces with no arithmetic. Dovetail spacing is the same job; Dovetails uses Rob Cosman's divider method.
Proportion in whole numbers
Walker writes about dividers as the tool for finding and applying proportions: how a part relates to its neighbor and to the whole. In another column he suggests fixing a proportion "in your inner eye" with dividers rather than by measuring (Honing in on proportions). The publisher's description of his book with Jim Tolpin, By Hand & Eye, says that pre-industrial artisans designed with simple whole-number ratios such as 1:2, 3:5 and 4:5 rather than formulas such as the golden section (By Hand & Eye, Lost Art Press). We have read the description, not the book. Convention
For a tote, a ratio helps with the sizes the contents do not fix: how high the sides stand against the ends, and where the handle sits. Set the dividers to the end's height on the stick, step it into five, and take two steps: that is a side two-fifths the height of the end. Try 1:2 or 1:3 the same way. Then look.
The cardboard mock-up
A ratio on a stick is not a tote in your hand. Before you cut wood, cut the ends and sides from a cereal box or a delivery carton at the stick's sizes, tape them up, and put the real things in. Then:
- Slide it into the space. Does it clear the trap, the shelf above, the door?
- Put your hand where the handle will be. Is there room for your fingers above the things beside it? From which side do you grip?
- Lift things in and out. Is the clearance enough? Too much?
- Look at it on the table. Do the sides look too tall, too low? Try another ratio and look again.
Change the stick to match what the mock-up taught you, not the other way round.
Proportion on a piece you already own. Take dividers to a chest, a table or a box you like. Set them to a small part, such as a drawer's height or a rail's width, and step it along the larger parts. You will often find it goes into them a whole number of times. Schwarz describes finding a 2:3 elevation this way on a known piece (The golden meaningless).
The golden section, and why one writer dropped it. In the same article Schwarz describes the golden section, about 1:1.618, as frustrating to design with, and turns to Walker's whole-number ratios instead. The publisher's description of By Hand & Eye makes the same contrast.
Making a pair of dividers. Tolpin and Walker's From Truths to Tools builds a try square, a straightedge and dividers starting from a circle and a point, according to its publisher's description (From Truths to Tools, Lost Art Press). We have not read the book and give no method from it.
The calculator against the stick. Enter the stick's inside sizes, read as numbers, into the cut list calculator and compare its part sizes with the parts you marked from offcuts. Agreement within a pencil line is a check on both. A difference usually means a joint depth taken twice, or a clearance added once on the stick and again in the calculator.
5. When numbers come in
Numbers earn their place in three jobs: buying wood, which is sold by number; the calculators, which take numbers; and telling a size to someone else, such as a lumberyard. Read them off the stick at the end, once, and write them on the Tote project sheet.
The inch
The inch is defined as exactly 25.4 mm. NIST's Handbook 44 states it, and NIST's page on length traces it to a 1959 agreement between English-speaking nations, effective July 1, 1959 (NIST Handbook 44, Appendix B; SI units: length). Physical principle So a millimeter rule and an inch tape measure the same thing, and the calculators accept either.
Reading a rule
Starrett's catalog gives a tip for close accuracy: measure between two lines on the rule rather than from its end (Starrett precision rules). Product-specific The end of a rule or the hook of a tape can be worn, bent or loose, and it is hard to line up exactly with an edge. Set the 1 in line on the mark instead, read the other mark, and take off the inch. Write it down before you lift the rule, which is where Schwarz's burned inch goes wrong. We found no maker's instructions for reading a tape measure's sliding hook, so we suggest the between-the-lines method for any size that matters.
Read straight down onto the line, not at an angle, and count the small divisions twice. Starrett notes that graduations of staggered lengths are easier to count than lines of one length; a rule with clear sixteenths is easier to read than a tape crowded with thirty-seconds.
Check that your tools agree
Lang recommends checking every measuring tool against the others and setting aside any that disagree. Lay your tape against your rule at 12 in; check your square with the flip test in Marking out. If two tools disagree, the story stick is unaffected, because nothing on it was read from either tool; you only need to decide which tool to trust for buying.
Writing the parts
On the tote sheet's parts table, write each part's finished length, width and thickness, and its grain direction. Rough sizes for sawing come from the cut list calculator, which adds Glen Huey's allowance of about 1 in over length and 1/4 in over width (Why wood warps). Joint sizes follow conventions from two sources: a housing a third of the wall's thickness and no more than half, and a rabbet about a third deep, at least 1/4 in and no more than 1/2 in in 3/4 in stock, from Fine Woodworking (All about rabbet and dado joints); a tenon a third of the thickness of the stock it passes through, from Popular Woodworking (Tenons rule). Convention In 3/4 in stock each comes to 1/4 in, which is one gauge setting for three joints. Keep the stick: you will mark parts from it, not from the sheet.
6. See it See it
Noor (fictional) sizes a cleaning tote. Noor's tote lives in the cabinet under her kitchen sink. The opening is 22 in wide; the clear height below the drain trap is 11 1/2 in. It carries two spray bottles 10 1/4 in tall with footprints 3 3/4 by 2 1/2 in, a scrub brush 8 1/2 in long, and a box of cloths 9 by 5 by 3 in. She chose 1/4 in clearance on each inside size and cut a clearance block. She is on the rabbet path, with 3/4 in common board.
Arrangement. On the table she first tries a divider across the tote, and finds the bottles would then stand under the handle, which runs the length; at 10 1/4 in they cannot fit under a handle and still clear 11 1/2 in. So the divider runs the length, and the handle runs over it. Compartment A holds the two bottles standing in a row along the length with the brush standing at the end of the row. Compartment B holds the cloths box standing on its long edge: 9 in long, 5 in tall, 3 in across.
Length. The cloths box is the longest thing in one compartment. She marks it on the length face, adds the block: 9 1/4 in, inside length. The bottles and the brush in their row mark below it.
Width. On the width face: a bottle's 2 1/2 in plus the block (2 3/4, compartment A), an offcut for the divider (3/4), the box's 3 in plus the block (3 1/4, compartment B). Inside width: 6 3/4 in.
Height. On the height face, from zero: the clear height, 11 1/2 in. An offcut for the bottom, 3/4 in, then a bottle standing on it: its top at 11 in. She sets the ends at 10 1/2 in tall, so with the bottom the tote stands 11 1/4 in and clears the trap by 1/4 in. The handle, 1 1/4 in high, sits with its top 3/4 in below the end tops, 10 1/2 in above the cabinet floor. Only the divider stands under it, far below. The bottles stand beside the handle, their tops 1/2 in above it.
Sides by ratio. With dividers set to the end's height, she steps it into five and takes two: just over 4 1/8 in. A 1x6 ripped to 4 1/4 in is within a sixteenth, and she takes 4 1/4 in for the sides and the divider.
Mock-up. Her cereal-box tote slides under the trap. With the bottles in, there is no room for her fingers on their side of the handle, so she grips from the cloths side, where the box stands only 5 in tall. The mock-up is where she found that.
Parts, from offcuts on the stick: sides 10 3/4 in long (inside length plus an end's thickness at each end) by 4 1/4 in, grain along the length, each with a rabbet 3/4 in wide by 1/4 in deep at each end; ends 10 1/2 in tall by 7 1/4 in wide (inside width plus a 1/4 in rabbet depth at each side), grain up and down, each with a groove 3/4 in wide by 1/4 in deep for the divider and a through mortise 1/4 by 5/8 in for the handle, centered over the divider; divider 9 3/4 in long by 4 1/4 in; handle 10 3/4 in long, 1 1/4 by 3/4 in, with a tenon 1/4 in thick by 5/8 in high through each end, flush; bottom two pieces of 1x6, 10 3/4 in long, ripped to about 4 1/8 in, nailed under side by side. Outside: 10 3/4 by 8 1/4 in, 11 1/4 in tall. The calculator flags the ends as wider than her 1x6, so she adds a 2 ft 1x8 for them (At the store).
Known: the contents, the clear height and the board's actual size. Assumed: that her boards have settled after a week flat in the kitchen. Open: whether the handle can sit below 11 1/2 in once the bottom's thickness is added, settled by the story stick: it can, with 1/4 in to spare. Whether the downstairs neighbor minds mallet work after 8 p.m. is settled by asking.
Hal (fictional), the dovetail path. Hal's garden tote holds two trowels 12 1/4 in long, a kneeling pad 16 by 11 by 1 1/2 in, and a seed tin 6 by 4 by 3 in. The trowels side by side with the tin at one end, and the pad on its long edge, set the inside length at 16 1/2 in with his 1/4 in clearance. Its divider also runs the length: compartment A is 2 in for the pad, compartment B 6 1/2 in for the trowels and tin, so the inside width is 9 1/4 in. His corners are through dovetails, so his ends need their grain running across: at 9 1/4 in tall they come from a 1x10, because a 1x8 is not wide enough. The pad stands above the handle, beside it, which the stick's height face shows before any wood is cut.
- Story stick, Woodcraft: making and marking a stick for cabinet work.
- Essential dividers, Popular Woodworking (George Walker): stepping off and the 45 degree limit.
- For dividers I fall, Popular Woodworking (Christopher Schwarz): why arithmetic invites mistakes, and three kinds of dividers.
- Measure, mark and lay out, Popular Woodworking (Robert Lang): marking one piece from another, pencils and knives.
7. Practice Practice
Minimum: one story stick marked with the inside length, inside width and the height checks for your tote, and the parts table on the tote sheet filled in. Time: about 1 1/2 hours with the mock-up. Materials: the things the tote will carry, a straight strip of pale wood or a paint stirrer, a sharp pencil, a small square or a book with a square corner, an offcut of your tote board, a clearance spacer, a cardboard box and tape, scissors. Dividers if you have them; a compass with a pencil works for stepping off.
- List the contents. Write each item on the Tote project sheet with a letter.
- Arrange and mark length. Try two arrangements on the table. Mark the longest compartment's run plus clearance as "inside length".
- Mark width. Compartment, offcut for the divider, compartment, each with clearance. Mark "inside width".
- Mark height and check the handle. Mark the space's clear height, the bottom's offcut, the tallest item, the end's top and the handle. Confirm nothing under the handle reaches its underside.
- Mock it up. Cut and tape a cardboard tote at the stick's sizes. Put the things in, slide it into the space, grip it.
- Mark the parts. Add offcuts and joint depths to get each part, and write them on the parts table, with grain direction.
- Check against the calculator (Go deeper; optional). Enter the inside sizes in the cut list calculator and compare its parts with yours.
8. Your setup Your setup
9. Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- Does every mark on the stick have a note, and is each face labeled with its direction?
- Did the inside sizes come from the things themselves plus a clearance you chose?
- Does the whole tote, bottom included, fit the space it must live in?
- Is everything under the handle shorter than the handle's underside, with room for a hand?
- Does the end grain direction match the corner joint, and does the cut list name a board wide enough for the ends?
- Are all parts written on the tote sheet with grain direction?
Worked example
Imani (fictional) sizes an art caddy for a 12 by 9 in sketchbook standing on its 12 in edge, about 1/2 in thick, a marker tin 6 by 4 by 1 1/2 in, and brushes up to 9 in long. The sketchbook sets the inside length at 12 1/2 in with clearance. Her divider runs the length: compartment A 3/4 in for the sketchbook, compartment B 4 1/4 in for the markers and brushes. She is left-handed, and in the mock-up she finds she wants to lift the sketchbook out with her left hand, so she turns the caddy round on her bench rather than changing the layout. Her corners are dovetails, so her stick's notes say "ends: grain across". Her stick passes every criterion. The only number she has read is the clearance, once, onto her block.
Common mistakes
- Marking two directions on one face. A width mark read as a length gives a part the wrong size. Notice it when a note does not match the face's label.
- Adding clearance twice. Once on the stick and again in the calculator. Notice it when the calculator's part is longer than the one you marked.
- Forgetting the bottom's thickness. The tote stands taller than its ends by the bottom. Check the full height against the space.
- Tall things under the handle. If the stick's height face shows an item above the handle's underside in a compartment under it, rearrange or run the divider the other way.
- Upright-grain ends on a dovetailed tote. Dovetails need the ends' grain running across. Notice it when the cut list takes the ends from a board narrower than the ends are tall.
What is still unresolved
- Carrying the stick's marks onto the boards with knife and gauge: Marking out.
- Buying the boards and how much they will move: Choosing wood.
- Cutting the rabbets, housings and grooves: Housings and rabbets; the handle's tenon: Mortise and tenon.
- Whether the finished tote carries what you intend: the real load, tried with care, or a furniture maker's view.