Marking out: reference faces, knife lines, squares and gauges
Mark every part from one face and one edge, check the square by flipping it, cut lines with a knife and set the gauge from the work.
Start here Essentials
At minimum this chapter asks you to check one square and mark one scrap from its references. Everything marked Go deeper is optional on a first pass.
- Check your square by the flip test. Draw a line along it from a straight edge, flip it over, draw again and look at the gap (Checking a square).
- Choose a face and an edge on a scrap, and mark them. A loop on the face, a V on the edge, touching (Reference faces).
- Knife a line square round the scrap. Start each face from the nick the last one left, and see whether the line meets itself (Pencil, knife and the knife wall).
- Set the gauge from a piece of the tote stock and gauge a line from the face. Pin trailing, light first pass (The marking gauge).
Minimum time: about 30 minutes. Done when: a scrap carries face and edge marks, a knife line that meets itself round all four faces, and a gauge line parallel to the face.
1. Reference faces Understand
A board from the store looks square and is not quite. Its faces are close to flat, its edges close to parallel, and its thickness close to the size on the label. None of those is exact, and a hand-planed board is less exact still. Marking out works with that fact instead of against it.
The method is to choose one face and one edge of every part and take every measurement from those two surfaces. They are the reference faces: the face side (the reference face, the broad surface) and the face edge (the reference edge, a narrow surface square to the face side). Convention Popular Woodworking traces the habit to hand planing, when nobody could assume that every side of a board was parallel to every other, so a woodworker trusted two surfaces and measured from them (Customary Marks).
Here is why it matters on the tote. Say one side of the tote is 3/4 in thick and the other is 25/32 in, a thirty-second fatter. You gauge the rabbet depth on each from the inside face. Both rabbets are now the same depth measured from the inside, so the inside faces line up at the corner and the end sits square in both. The extra thirty-second ends up on the outside, where a plane can take it off. Gauge the same rabbets from the outside face instead, and the difference lands inside the box, where the end board sees it as a twist. One reference per direction means the errors in the wood go somewhere you chose.
Choosing which face and which edge
On a box, the inside face of each wall is the usual face side, because the joints that have to agree (rabbets, housings, the inside of a dovetail) are cut from the inside. Christopher Schwarz notes that the traditional face mark typically also marks the inside surface of a cabinet (Make Your Mark). Preference For the tote's walls we choose the bottom edge as the face edge. It is the edge the bottom is nailed to and the edge that has to sit flat, and it lets the tops absorb any small difference in width, where a plane can even them after assembly.
Choose the flatter, straighter surfaces when you have a choice. Lay a straightedge (the edge of a square's blade will do on short parts) across the face and along the edge and look for light underneath. If a face rocks on the table, it is a poor reference until it is planed; Planing a board square makes one flat and one edge straight and square to it, and marks them as it goes.
The marks
The marks are pencil, quick, and readable by anyone who learned the same system. Schwarz describes the common set in Make Your Mark:
| Mark | Where it goes | What it says |
|---|---|---|
| Face mark: a loop like a curly tail | On the face side, its tail running off onto the edge chosen as face edge | This face is flat and is the one measured from. On a box, it is usually also the inside |
| Edge mark: a V, its point touching the tail of the face mark (Charles Hayward draws it more like a lower-case h) | On the face edge | This edge is straight and square to the face side |
| Cabinetmaker's triangle: one triangle drawn across several parts at once | Across the top edges of an assembly, pointing to the front or the top | Which part goes where, which way up and which way round |
| Square-corner mark: an arc with R inside (Hayward) | On the face, at a corner | This corner has been checked square |
Schwarz prefers Hayward's h to a plain V, because a V can be read as part of a cabinetmaker's triangle. Pick one and keep to it. Some woodworkers also bend the face mark's tail to point the way the grain runs on that face, which helps when you plane it again.
The tote needs one more set. Its four walls look alike once they are cut, and an end turned round puts a mortise on the wrong side. Preference We letter the corners: draw the triangle across the top edges of all four walls laid side by side in the order they go round the box, then write A, B, C and D at each joint so the two pieces that meet carry the same letter. Write "in" on each inside face if it helps you. All of this is pencil on surfaces that will be planed or hidden, so it costs nothing.
2. Checking a square
Every line across a board is drawn against a square, so a square that is out puts the same error into every part. Check it before you trust it, new or old.
A try square has a fixed blade (the narrow steel arm, also called the tongue) set at a right angle to a thicker stock that bears against the edge of the work. A combination square has a sliding head on a rule, and its square is only as good as the head's lock on the day. Either works for the tote. Popular Woodworking suggests a 6 in square for small projects (All About Try Squares); the tote's widest parts are 7 1/4 in for Noor (fictional) and 10 3/4 in for Hal (fictional), so a 6 in blade reaches across most of the narrow parts and a 12 in blade reaches across all of them.
The flip test
- Find a straight edge. The edge of a board planed straight, or a sheet of plywood or MDF with a factory edge. It needs to be straight. It does not need to be square to anything, because the test compares the square only with itself.
- Draw the first line. Hold the stock firmly against the edge and draw a fine line along the outside of the blade, as far out as it goes. Popular Woodworking uses a knife; Robert Lang uses a sharp pencil. A knife line is finer.
- Flip the square over so the stock bears on the same edge from the other side, and bring the same edge of the blade up to the first line.
- Look at the gap. If the blade lies along the line from end to end, the square is square at that edge. If it touches at one end and leaves a gap at the other, draw a second line.
Physical principle The gap between the two lines is twice the actual error. Lang explains it in Woodworking Essentials: Measure, Mark and Lay Out: flipping the square mirrors its error, so the first line leans one way by the error and the second leans the other way by the same amount. A gap of 1/32 in at the end of a 6 in blade means the square is out by 1/64 in over 6 in. That is small on paper. On the tote, a side whose end is cut 1/64 in out of square over its width leaves a corner that opens on one face and closes on the other, which is exactly what a rabbet or a dovetail shows off.
A square has two edges on its blade, inside and outside. Test both: one can be right and the other out. On a combination square, test it locked at the extension you use. Lang adds one more habit that costs nothing: compare your measuring tools with each other, and put away any that disagree.
The flip test tells you whether this square, at this edge, on this day, matches itself within what your eye and your line can show. It does not certify any tool, and neither does this manual. A square can be filed true (see the Go deeper section below), but for a new square that fails, we recommend returning it to the seller rather than filing it. For an old square you inherited, the test tells you whether to trust it; how far out is too far for your work is a judgment you make from the joint in front of you.
3. Pencil, knife and the knife wall
Lang's point about pencils is plain arithmetic. A soft pencil line can be wider than the tolerance the joint needs, and then nobody knows which side of the line was meant. He suggests a 0.5 mm mechanical pencil, which draws a much finer line than a No. 2. For rough cuts, where the part is still an inch over length, a pencil is right: it is quick and it shows.
For a cut that sets a finished size, use a knife line: a line cut into the surface with a marking knife. It has no width to speak of, it does not smudge, and because it has severed the surface fibers, the saw or the chisel has something physical to register against. A marking knife is a short, stiff blade sharpened for this. Many have a single bevel with one flat side, which runs against the square; a spear-point knife has two bevels and works from either side.
The knife wall
A knife wall is a knife line opened into a shallow V groove, with one wall straight down and one sloped. Yoav Liberman credits the term to Paul Sellers and describes the method in An Intro to Marking Knives:
- Knife the line. Square on the mark, the flat of the knife against the blade of the square, the bevel facing the waste (the side that will be cut away). Light pressure on the first pass, then a few more passes, each a little firmer. He goes 1/32 to 1/16 in deep.
- Cut the ramp. A chisel, bevel up, about 1/16 in on the waste side, held at about 45 degrees, pushed down toward the knife line so the fibers shear off. Repeat along the line.
- Set the saw in the V. The saw tends to settle against the straight wall, the one the knife made, so the cut lands on the line instead of straddling it.
Sellers uses a knife wall for tenon shoulders, dovetail shoulders and the sides of housings, and says it leaves a square shoulder straight off the saw, or one a chisel can trim to, so a shoulder plane becomes a luxury (Knifewalls). Sawing to a line starts every finished cut in one.
Squaring a line round a board
A finished crosscut needs its line on all four faces, so you can see the saw arrive at the far side. The method from All About Try Squares is short:
- Nick the corner. Put the knife point on the mark at the edge of the face side and press a deep nick into the corner.
- Bring the square to the knife. With the knife still in the nick, slide the square up until the blade touches the knife. Then knife across, several light passes rather than one heavy one.
- Go round the corner. At the far side the line leaves its own nick in the corner. Drop the knife into it on the next face, slide the square up to the knife, and knife across. Repeat on each face.
Which edge the stock bears on matters. Keep the stock on the face side or the face edge every time. On the face side and the opposite face, the stock bears on the face edge. On the face edge and the opposite edge, it bears on the face side. Every line then comes from a reference.
Physical principle If the board is square and so is your square, the line arrives back at its starting nick. If it misses, the miss tells you something: the board is out of square in section, or the square is, or the stock rocked. That is information worth having before you saw, not after.
Preference We hatch the waste side of every line with a few pencil strokes. It takes a second and it settles which side the saw goes on when you come back to the board the next evening.
4. The marking gauge
A marking gauge scribes a line parallel to an edge or a face. It has a head (the fence that bears against the reference), a beam (the arm that slides through the head and locks) and a pin near the end of the beam that scratches the line. A cutting gauge has a small knife instead of a pin and cuts cleanly across the grain as well as along it. Dean Jansa's Mystery of the Marking Gauge (Popular Woodworking, December 2006) is the source for most of this section.
Set it from the work
Jansa calls this gauging rather than measuring: the gauge carries a size from one board to another with no number in between. Set it with the mating board, and there is no figure to misread. On the tote, that means:
- Rabbet width: set the gauge to the thickness of the end board itself, by setting the pin to the far face of the end with the head against its near face.
- Dovetail baseline: set it to the thickness of the mating board, the way Jansa describes.
- Width of a part: set it to a part already cut, or to the mark on the story stick (Measuring without numbers).
- Depth of a rabbet or housing: one-third of the wall, which is about 1/4 in in 3/4 in stock. Here you need a number or a division: set the gauge off a rule, or step the thickness into thirds with dividers.
Once it is set, mark every part that shares that size before you change the setting. Jansa makes the point that each mark is then exactly the same as the last. If you own one gauge, plan the order so that each setting is used up before you move on.
Run it from the face
Jansa quotes Holtzapffel's 1846 rule that every piece is gauged from the face side, so the parts sit flush when they are put together. Run thickness, rabbet depth and housing depth lines with the head on the face side. Run width lines with the head on the face edge.
How to hold and push it
- Tilt it so the pin trails. Jansa says the pin is rarely upright in use; it trails behind as you push. The more upright the pin, the deeper it cuts, and you control that by rolling your wrist.
- Light first pass. On long grain he makes the first pass with the pin barely touching, then a second, slightly steeper pass if the line needs to be deeper.
- Press the head, not the pin. A pin tends to follow the grain, Jansa notes, and a gauge pushed down hard on its pin will be steered off by it. Keep the pressure sideways, head against the reference.
- Across the grain, lighter still, or use a cutting gauge, so the pin does not tear the fibers.
Gauge lines also make planing to thickness possible by hand: Jansa sets the gauge at the thinnest spot of a board, marks round all four edges and planes down to the line, which removes only what uniformity needs. Planing a board square uses exactly that.
| Tool | Marks | Bears on | Set from |
|---|---|---|---|
| Square and knife | Lines across a board: lengths, shoulders, housing sides | Face side or face edge | A mark from the story stick, or the mating part held in place |
| Marking gauge | Lines along a board: widths, thicknesses, rabbet and housing depths, dovetail baselines | Face side or face edge | The mating part, a part already cut, or the story stick |
| Pencil | Rough lengths and widths, face and edge marks, waste hatching, part letters | Anything | The story stick or a rule; anywhere in the extra inch is fine |
5. Marking the tote's parts
The order follows the cuts. Rough sizes come first and finished sizes last, so the two kinds of line do not compete on the same surface.
- Rough lengths in pencil. Glen Huey of Popular Woodworking rough-cuts parts about 1 in over length and 1/4 in over width before final sizing (Why Wood Warps). A pencil line and a square are enough here. The cut list calculator gives each part's rough size and the length of board it takes, kerfs included.
- Reference faces after planing. Once a part is planed flat, straight and square, choose and mark its face side and face edge. If you skipped planing because the store board is good enough, still choose and mark them: the marks matter more than the planing.
- Width and thickness with the gauge, from the face edge and the face side, then plane to the lines.
- Finished lengths with the knife, squared round from the face edge, the positions taken from the story stick.
- Joints last: rabbets, housings, mortises and dovetails, each gauged from the face side and knifed from the face edge, with the mating part used as the measure wherever it can be.
Noor's parts show the pattern (sizes from her cut list; your own come from your stick and the calculator):
| Part (finished) | Face side and face edge | Knife lines (from the face edge) | Gauge lines |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sides, 2 at 10 3/4 by 4 1/4 in, grain along the length | Inside face; bottom edge | Both ends; the rabbet shoulder 3/4 in in from each end | Width 4 1/4 in from the bottom edge; rabbet depth 1/4 in from the inside face; rabbet width set from the end board itself |
| Ends, 2 at 10 1/2 tall by 7 1/4 in wide (the full 1x8), grain up and down | Inside face; one long edge | Top and bottom | Groove depth 1/4 in from the inside face; the handle mortise's two sides, from the face edge |
| Divider, 9 3/4 long by 4 1/4 in high | Either face; bottom edge | Both ends | Height 4 1/4 in from the bottom edge |
| Handle, 10 3/4 by 1 1/4 by 3/4 in | One face; bottom edge | Both ends; the tenon shoulders | Tenon thickness (1/4 in) from the face side, tenon height (5/8 in) from the bottom edge |
| Bottom, two pieces 10 3/4 in long, ripped to about 4 1/8 in | Underside; one edge each | Both ends | Width from the face edge, for the rip |
Three details from that table. First, the ends come from a 2 ft 1x8, used at its full 7 1/4 in width with the grain running up and down, which the rabbet path allows. Their 10 1/2 in height is cut across the grain. Draw a grain arrow on each end so the board is not turned the wrong way before it is cut. Second, the divider's slot in each end is laid out from the divider itself: stand the divider on the end at its mark from the story stick, knife along both of its faces, and the slot is exactly as wide as the divider, whatever its planed thickness turned out to be. Because Noor's end grain runs up and down, that slot runs with the grain, so strictly it is a groove rather than a housing; Housings and rabbets cuts both with the same saw and chisel. Third, the handle's mortise is centered over that slot, so mark the slot first and take the mortise from it.
Log the attempts on the practice sheet: what you marked, whether the knife line met itself, and what the flip test showed.
Go deeper 6. Pencil in softwood, filing a square and the bevel
Pencil against knife in softwood
This chapter's default is a knife line for every finished size. Paul Sellers makes an exception for dovetails in pine: he lays them out in pencil, because pine compresses differently from hardwood, and a joint cut exactly to knife lines in pine would be too tight to go together straight off the saw. The fibers crush as the parts seat, and friction tightens the fit. He adds that oak, being ring-porous, compresses more than maple or cherry (Understanding Softwood Dovetails). That is one practitioner's method. Noor's common board is probably a pine, species unknown, and her corners are rabbets, where a knife line still sets the shoulder; if she later tries dovetails in the same stock, Sellers' note is worth testing on an offcut. Test it
Filing a square true
Popular Woodworking's method: knife two lines by the flip test so they touch at one point, set a sliding bevel to half the angle between them, scribe that angle on the blade, and file away the material to it (All About Try Squares). It works on a cheap or old square whose maker will not take it back. On a new square, returning it is quicker and leaves the maker's surfaces intact, which is why the chapter recommends that instead.
The flip test and a sliding bevel
A sliding bevel holds any angle. Physical principle Set to a right angle, it can be flip-tested exactly like a square. Set to any other angle, flipping it draws the angle and its mirror image instead of a single line, so the flip does not check it. That mirror is what a dovetail layout uses: one setting marks both sides of every tail. Dovetails sets the bevel from a slope.
7. See it See it
Imani's square, and her left hand. Imani (fictional) is left-handed and works at a shared basement bench with a combination square that belongs to the house. Before she marks her cherry caddy, she flip-tests it against the factory edge of a sheet of plywood. Locked at the extension she will use, the outside edge leaves a gap she can just see with a knife line; she lays a rule across it and calls it about 1/64 in at the end of the blade, which is an error of about 1/128 in. The inside edge lies dead on the line. She marks the outside edge with tape and uses the inside edge only. For her own hand she mirrors the setup: the square in her right hand with the stock against the face edge, the knife in her left, pulled toward her along the blade. The house's knife is a right-bevel knife, which puts its bevel against the square in her left hand, so she uses a spear-point knife with two bevels instead.
Known: the contents of the caddy, the basement's humidity, the square's two flip-test results. Assumed: that nobody resets the shared square's head between her sessions; she settles this by flip-testing it again at the start of each one. Open: whether to plane her 13/16 in stock to 3/4 in. That changes her dovetail baselines, so she waits to gauge any baseline until the boards are at their final thickness. She settles it herself after Planing a board square.
- All About Try Squares, Popular Woodworking: the flip test step by step, the filing correction and the knife-in-the-nick method for going round a corner.
- An Intro to Marking Knives, Yoav Liberman: a knife wall cut with a knife and a chisel, with photographs of each stage.
- Make Your Mark, Christopher Schwarz: the face, edge, square-corner and triangle marks drawn out, with Hayward's and Charlesworth's versions.
- Mystery of the Marking Gauge, Dean Jansa (PDF): how a gauge is held, why the pin trails, and gauging instead of measuring.
8. Practice Practice
Minimum: one square flip-tested, and one scrap with face and edge marks, a knife line round it that meets itself, and one gauge line. Time: about 45 minutes. Materials: a square, a marking knife, a sharp pencil, a marking gauge, a straight edge for the flip test (a sheet of plywood or a planed board), and a scrap of the tote stock about 12 in long.
- Flip-test the square. Both edges of the blade. Write the result on the practice sheet: square, or out by about how much at which edge.
- Choose and mark the scrap's face side and face edge. Sight along them first and pick the flatter face and the straighter edge.
- Knife a line square round the scrap, about 2 in from one end, stock on the references every time. See whether the line meets its starting nick. Do it three times, a couple of inches apart, and note whether the misses are the same size and on the same corner; a repeated miss points at the board or the square, a random one at your hand.
- Set the gauge from the tote stock (a rabbet width set from the thickness of a piece of the same board) and run that line along the scrap from the face side. Then set it to about 1/4 in and run a depth line along the face edge.
- Cut one knife wall on one of the lines, chisel ramp and all, if you have a chisel. It is the start of every finished cut in Sawing to a line.
- Mark a full set of tote parts (Go deeper; optional). With your cut list from the calculator and your story stick, mark rough lengths on the board in pencil and letter the walls with a triangle.
9. Your setup Your setup
10. Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- Does your square pass the flip test at the edge you use? If not, do you know which edge and by roughly how much?
- Does every part carry a face mark and an edge mark, and do the two marks touch at the same corner?
- Does each knife line meet itself round all four faces, within the width of the line?
- Was every gauge line run with the head on the face side or the face edge, and set from the work rather than read off a rule where the work could give it?
- Is the waste side of every finished line hatched?
- Can someone else pick up your four walls and put them in order from the letters and the triangle alone?
Worked example
Noor (fictional) marks the first of her two sides. She chooses the inside face, whose growth rings arch away from it and whose surface lies flatter on the table, and the edge that sits straight against a rule, and marks them with a loop and a V. From her story stick she transfers the two end marks to the bottom edge, and the two rabbet shoulders 3/4 in in from them. She squares the first end line round with the knife. It misses its starting nick by about the width of the line at the back corner. She re-squares from the face edge only, keeping the stock off the opposite edge, and the second line meets. The first miss came from moving the stock to the far edge on the last face. Then she sets her gauge from the end board for the rabbet width and to 1/4 in for its depth, runs both on the second side before resetting, and hatches the waste. The criteria hold: references marked, lines meeting, gauge lines from the face, waste hatched.
Common mistakes
- Moving the stock to the far edge on one face. The line then comes from an edge nobody checked, and it misses its nick. Keep the stock on a reference.
- Gauging from the outside face. The joint depths then vary with every board's thickness, and the differences end up inside the box.
- Pushing the gauge pin down hard. The pin follows the grain and drags the line off. Press the head against the reference instead and let the pin trail.
- Knifing a rough length. A knife line in the waste of an inch-over part is wasted effort, and a stray knife line on a finished face has to be planed out.
- Trusting a square because it is new. Test it the day you open it.
- Resetting the gauge halfway through a set of parts. The second setting will differ from the first by a little. Use up each setting first.
What is still unresolved
- Whether a part is flat and square enough to mark from: Planing a board square.
- Where the lengths come from in the first place: Measuring without numbers.
- Whether the saw lands on the line you drew: Sawing to a line.
- How a dovetail's slope is set and marked: Dovetails.
- Which square, knife and gauge to buy, or whether an inherited one is worth keeping: The first tools and the Tools and wood sheet.