Sawing to a line
Sawing and planing

Sawing to a line: crosscuts, rip cuts and staying square

Choose rip or crosscut teeth, start in a knife wall on the waste side, keep the saw upright, and find out why a cut wanders.

Start here Essentials

At minimum this chapter asks for a run of square crosscuts on scrap, made on a bench hook with one saw. Everything marked Go deeper is optional on a first pass.

  1. Knife a line square round a scrap and hatch the waste side (Marking out).
  2. Hold the scrap on the bench hook, against the fence, the line just past the fence's end (Starting and staying on the line; the hook is made in Make a bench hook this weekend).
  3. Start the cut in the knife wall on the waste side and saw with light pressure, using the crosscut edge of the ryoba (Which saw, and which edge).
  4. Check the cut with the square, on the face and on the edge, and note which way any error leans (When a cut wanders).

Minimum time: about 40 minutes. Done when: five crosscuts on scrap in a row meet the knife line on both faces, checked with the square.

1. How a saw cuts Understand

A handsaw is a row of small cutting edges on a thin steel plate. It cuts on one stroke only: a Western saw on the push, a Japanese saw on the pull. The return stroke does nothing but bring the teeth back. Two other facts follow from the plate being thin and long. It follows the path it starts in, and it is easier to keep in a straight path than to steer back into one. Both facts shape everything in this chapter.

Rip teeth and crosscut teeth

Wood is a bundle of long fibers, and a saw meets them in one of two ways.

  • A rip cut runs along the grain, parallel to the fibers, as when a board is cut to width. Rip teeth are filed straight across, so each tooth works like a tiny chisel, lifting a chip from the end of the fibers.
  • A crosscut runs across the grain, as when a board is cut to length. Crosscut teeth are filed to points with alternating bevels, so each tooth works like a knife, severing the fibers on each side of the cut before the waste between them crumbles out.

Either kind of tooth will cut either way, badly. Rip teeth used across the grain tear fibers and leave a ragged edge; crosscut teeth used along the grain cut slowly and clog.

Teeth per inch, rake, set and kerf

Four terms describe a saw's teeth, and Lee Valley's page for its Veritas tenon saws gives a figure for each (Veritas Rip and Crosscut Tenon Saws). Product-specific

  • Teeth per inch (tpi, sometimes ppi for points per inch): more teeth cut slower and finer, fewer cut faster and rougher.
  • Rake: how far the front of each tooth leans back from upright. More rake is easier to push and less aggressive.
  • Set: the teeth are bent slightly outward, alternately to each side, so the groove they cut is wider than the plate and the plate does not rub.
  • Kerf: the width of the groove the saw cuts, which is the plate's thickness plus the set on both sides. The kerf is wood that turns to dust.
Veritas rip tenon sawVeritas crosscut tenon saw
CutsWith the grainAcross the grain
Teeth per inch912
Rake14 degrees15 degrees
Tooth shapeFiled straight acrossAlternating 15 degree bevels that sever the fibers rather than tear them
Plate and setPlate 0.024 in thick, set 0.003 in to each side
Kerf (our arithmetic)About 0.030 in, a little under 1/32 in

Those are one maker's numbers for one pair of saws. A pull saw's plate is thinner and its kerf narrower; a big Western handsaw's is wider. What carries over to every saw is the reason the kerf matters: it has to go somewhere. Physical principle Saw down the middle of your line and each part loses half a kerf. Saw on the waste side, with the edge of the kerf just touching the line, and the part keeps its full size. That is why Marking out hatches the waste and the knife wall's straight side faces the part.

2. Which saw, and which edge

This manual's default first saw is a ryoba: a Japanese pull saw with two cutting edges on one plate, rip teeth on one edge and crosscut teeth on the other. A woodworker trained in Japan, writing for Woodcraft, recommends the ryoba as the starter saw for anyone new to the pull stroke, and gives its sizes by blade length: 210 mm (8 1/4 in) for furniture, 240 mm (9 1/2 in) for general carpentry, 270 mm (10 3/4 in) for larger work (Japanese Saw Guide for Beginners). The tote's parts are 3/4 in thick and at most a foot long, so the 210 mm size suits them; the 240 mm is fine too.

Why a ryoba first:

  • One saw does both kinds of cut. Noor's (fictional) tote needs crosscuts for every length and rips for the widths she cuts from her 1x6, and she can afford one saw.
  • The pull stroke keeps the plate in tension, so it can be thin. The same guide credits the thin blade and thin kerf with needing less effort.
  • The blades are replaceable. The guide notes that the crosscut teeth are easily damaged and hard to resharpen. A blunt or damaged ryoba blade is replaced, not sharpened, so nobody on the kitchen-table path has to learn saw filing.

The guide also names the ryoba's limits. Its flexible plate can feel hard to keep straight at first, and its answer is to cut in stages so the first kerf guides the rest (Starting and staying on the line). In a deep crosscut, the rip teeth on the other edge can mar the smooth crosscut surface, which is what single-edged saws are for. Neither limit matters in 3/4 in stock.

Physical principle Which edge to use follows the grain, not the part. A cut along the fibers takes the rip edge; a cut across them takes the crosscut edge. Most cuts on the tote are crosscuts (lengths) or rips (widths), but Noor's ends are the case that catches people: their grain runs up and down, so cutting them to 10 1/2 in tall is a crosscut even though it is the end's "height". Look at the grain, not the drawing.

Other first saws are reasonable. The Go deeper section below compares Western backsaws and handsaws, which suit a reader who already owns one, like Hal (fictional) with his father's 26 in handsaw.

3. Starting and staying on the line

Most of a cut's accuracy is decided in its first few strokes. Yoav Liberman calls them perhaps the most crucial ones in the whole cut (An Intro to Marking Knives). After that, the kerf guides the plate, for better or worse.

Hold the work

For crosscuts on short parts, use a bench hook: a flat board with a cleat underneath that hooks over the table edge and a fence on top that the work is pushed against. Gravity and the fence hold the work, with no clamp (Make a Pair of Bench Hooks, Popular Woodworking). With a pull saw, the stroke draws the work toward you, so set the hook up so the pull presses the work into the fence, not away from it. Test it If the work creeps on the pull stroke, turn the hook round or hold the work against the fence harder with your free hand. A shop on a table covers the table, the hook and clamping long rips.

Start in the knife wall

  1. Knife the line and cut the chisel ramp on the waste side, as in Marking out.
  2. Set the saw in the V, teeth on the far corner, plate against the straight wall. Liberman tells his students using an all-purpose Japanese saw to rest light pressure on the saw's spine for the first strokes, so it cannot jump out of the V, and to let up once the kerf is about 1/8 in deep.
  3. Short, light strokes at first, at a low angle, using the finer teeth near the handle end of the rip edge if you are ripping (the Woodcraft guide notes they are smaller there for starting).
  4. Lengthen the strokes once the kerf is established, using as much of the blade as is comfortable.

Cut in stages

The Woodcraft guide's method for a straight crosscut with a ryoba is to start at the top corner and saw across the top face first. When the kerf runs nearly all the way across the top, change the saw's angle so the top kerf guides the cut down the near face. Then down the far face. The finished cut has followed lines you can see on three faces, and the kerf on the top face steered the rest.

Let the saw cut

Liberman's students saw naturally once the kerf is started; the Woodcraft guide credits the pull saw with needing less effort than a push saw. Pressing down hard does not make a pull saw cut faster in any useful way; it bends a thin plate and drives it off line. Test it If a cut wanders, try halving the pressure and holding the handle more loosely on the next one, and compare. A loose grip lets the saw run in its own kerf; a tight grip steers it, and the steering is what wanders.

Stand behind the cut

Physical principle You can see whether a plate is upright only when your eye is in the plane of the cut, above the blade and looking down its length. Seen from one side, a lean is invisible until you look at the far face. Stand so your eye, your forearm and the saw are in one line with the cut. On a kitchen table, that often means standing at the end of the table rather than at its side; A shop on a table covers where the hook goes.

Limits

A saw cuts skin as readily as wood, and nothing in this chapter makes sawing harmless. Keep the hand that holds the work behind the fence and away from the line the saw will leave by; on a pull saw that line comes toward you, so the free hand stays on the far side of the cut. Start strokes slowly so a skating saw goes nowhere fast. OSHA's hand tool guidance, written for workplaces, says to direct saws away from other people (Hand and Power Tools). For a cut, follow a first aid source rather than this manual: MedlinePlus on cuts and puncture wounds and the American Red Cross on wounds say when to call for help. A doctor settles anything beyond that.

4. When a cut wanders

A cut that drifts off its line has a cause, and the cause is either you or the saw. The way to tell them apart is the pattern. Test it If the cut drifts the same way every time, whatever you change about your stance and grip, suspect the saw. If it drifts differently from cut to cut, or improves when you slow down, it is technique, which practice fixes.

A dull or kinked saw is a tool problem, not a skill problem, and no amount of practice will make it cut straight. That is worth knowing early, because a beginner with a bad saw usually blames their own hands.

What you seeLikely causeWhat to try
The cut starts beside the line, or the saw jumps out on the first strokesNo knife wall, or too much speed and pressure at the startCut a knife wall; rest light pressure on the spine for the first strokes; start slower (Liberman)
Square on the top face, out on the bottom faceThe saw leans; your eye is not over the bladeStand in line with the cut; saw in stages, top face first, then each side face (Woodcraft)
A gentle curve, different from cut to cutSteering: a tight grip, heavy pressure or short, jerky strokesLooser grip, lighter pressure, longer strokes. Repeat five cuts and compare
A steady drift to the same side on every cut, whoever sawsThe saw: set uneven from side to side, or teeth duller on one side, so one side cuts more than the other Physical principleSwap to another saw and repeat. If the drift goes, the first saw needs a sharpener or a new blade
The saw binds or the cut wanders at one part of the strokeA bent plate. A slight bend may not matter; a bad kink makes the saw bind (Fine Woodworking)Sight down the plate; make a test cut. A kinked saw goes to a saw sharpener or is retired; a ryoba gets a new blade
The saw skates and will not bite; a crosscut leaves fuzzy, torn edgesDull or damaged teeth, or the rip edge used across the grainCheck which edge you are using. Then a new blade (ryoba) or sharpening (Western saw)

Fine Woodworking's guide to old handsaws starts every inspection at the plate: sight down it, and judge the bend. A slight bend can be worked out or may not matter to the cut; a bad kink makes the saw bind, and the restorer interviewed there does not spend time on one (A Buyer's Guide to Antique Handsaws). Hal's saw in the fictional example below is a case of that.

The When it goes wrong page has the same faults in a shorter table, beside the faults from planing and joints, and the practice sheet is where to log which cuts wandered and which way.

5. Cutting the tote's parts

The tote's parts are cut twice: once to rough size, and once to finished size after planing. Glen Huey of Popular Woodworking rough-cuts parts about 1 in over length and 1/4 in over width (Why Wood Warps). The extra gives the plane something to remove and lets a slightly wandering rough cut do no harm.

  1. Crosscut to rough length from pencil lines. Shorter pieces are easier to handle on a table than a 6 ft board. The cut list calculator lists each part's rough size and the board length it takes, with a kerf allowed between parts.
  2. Rip to rough width, sawing on the waste side of a gauge line run from the face edge. Clamp the board so the cut overhangs the table edge, and saw from both faces in turn if you can, so you can see the line on each.
  3. Plane to finished width and thickness (Planing a board square).
  4. Crosscut to finished length on the bench hook, in a knife wall squared round from the face edge, the saw on the waste side.
  5. True the ends on a shooting board if they need it (also in Planing a board square).

Paul Sellers saws to gauge lines and warns that leaving too much to trim works against you (Margins in Cuts for Hand Work). The rough cuts are where you leave plenty. The finished cuts are where you aim to need nothing but a pass or two on the shooting board.

For Noor's tote, from her cut list: the two sides (10 3/4 in finished, grain along the length), the divider (9 3/4 in) and the handle (10 3/4 in) are crosscut from a 1x6, then ripped to 4 1/4 in, 4 1/4 in and 1 1/4 in. The two bottom pieces are 10 3/4 in long and ripped to about 4 1/8 in. The ends come from a 2 ft 1x8 used at its full 7 1/4 in width, so they need no rip: each is one crosscut to rough length and one to 10 1/2 in. Because their grain runs up and down, those are crosscuts made across a 7 1/4 in width, the widest crosscuts on her tote. They are the ones to make in stages.

Go deeper 6. Western and Japanese saws, filing, and long rips

Western saws

A Western saw cuts on the push. Its plate is thicker than a pull saw's, because a thin plate pushed from behind would buckle. A backsaw stiffens the plate with a folded steel or brass spine along its top edge, which limits the depth of cut and keeps the plate straight; tenon saws and dovetail saws are backsaws. A handsaw or panel saw has no spine and cuts as deep as the work.

The sources we read differ on the first joinery saw, and the differences are mostly about cost and sharpening:

  • Paul Sellers names a 10 in, 17 tpi gent's saw for dovetails and shoulders, and warns against anything with 20 tpi (You Don't Need Much).
  • Richard Maguire, The English Woodworker, suggests a Japanese back saw as the first joinery saw when in doubt, because it is cheap and needs no sharpening, and says to choose rip; for bigger cuts he suggests a cheap hardpoint panel saw with rip capability (Which Hand Tools Do I Need To Get Started?).
  • Lee Valley sells its tenon saws as a rip and crosscut pair, and its dovetail saws at 14 and 20 tpi (Veritas Rip and Crosscut Tenon Saws).
  • The Woodcraft guide says that a Japanese backsaw, the dozuki, is the next step after the ryoba for joints that need little or no paring.

We chose the ryoba because one saw covers both kinds of cut on the tote, and its blade is replaced rather than sharpened. A reader who already owns a good backsaw has no reason to buy one. The first tools covers buying either.

Filing a saw

Western saws with ordinary steel teeth can be sharpened with a file and a saw set. This manual does not teach it: Maguire's point is that a beginner does not need to know how to sharpen a saw to start, and Sellers chooses a saw that can be resharpened. For a dull Western saw, a saw sharpening service is one answer. Woodcraft describes Japanese crosscut teeth as hard to resharpen and the blades as replaceable, so a dull ryoba usually gets a new blade.

Long rips by hand

The tote's longest rip is about a foot, and a ryoba handles it. Ripping a long board to width by hand is slower, and it is where a longer saw with coarser rip teeth earns its place. Clamp the board flat with the line overhanging the table, gauge the line on both faces, and saw from one face for a few inches, then turn the board and saw from the other, so the cut follows a line you can see on each side. Move the clamp along as the cut advances, keeping the free end supported so it does not pinch the saw or break off at the end of the cut.

7. See it See it

Fictional example

Hal's bent saw. Hal (fictional), 71, inherited his father's 26 in handsaw with the rest of the tools. Sighting down the plate from the handle, he sees a slight bend near the toe, the far end. Before cutting any tote parts in his yellow-poplar, he makes a test cut. He gauges a line along a 14 in offcut of 1x8, clamps it with the line overhanging the bench in his garage, and rips along it with long strokes. The first 8 in run true. Each stroke that reaches the toe binds a little, and over the last few inches the kerf wanders about 1/16 in toward the bend. He makes the same cut with a new ryoba: it runs to the line.

Known: the bend is there and where it is; the saw binds and drifts when that part of the plate is in the cut, and the ryoba does not, so it is the saw and not his hands. Assumed: that the set is even, since the first 8 in ran true; a saw sharpener can confirm it. Open: whether the bend can be taken out. Fine Woodworking's guide says a slight bend can sometimes be worked out; a saw sharpener or restorer settles it for this saw. Until then Hal cuts his tote parts with the ryoba and uses the handsaw, with short strokes that keep the toe out of the cut, for rough cuts in the garden.

8. Practice Practice

Minimum: five crosscuts in a row on a scrap, each in a knife wall on the bench hook, each checked on both faces with the square. Time: about 40 minutes for the crosscuts, 30 more for the rips. Materials: a ryoba or other saw, a bench hook, a square, a marking knife, a chisel for the ramp if you have one, a pencil, a marking gauge for the rips, a clamp, and a scrap of the tote stock 12 to 18 in long.

  1. Knife five lines square round the scrap, about 1 in apart, and hatch the waste side of each.
  2. Saw the first one on the bench hook, in stages: top face, near face, far face.
  3. Check it with the square on the cut face and the edge. Write on the practice sheet whether it met the line on both faces and, if not, which way it leaned.
  4. Repeat for all five, changing one thing at a time if a cut wanders: lighter pressure, looser grip, eye over the blade. The pattern across five cuts tells you more than any one.
  5. Rip a strip (Go deeper; optional). Gauge a line 1 1/4 in from the face edge along the scrap, clamp it with the line overhanging the table, and rip it on the waste side with the rip edge. Check it with the gauge line on both faces.
  6. Test an old saw (Go deeper; optional). Sight down its plate, then make the same rip with it and with a saw you trust, and compare the two kerfs.

9. Your setup Your setup

10. Check your work Check your work

Criteria

  • Does each cut meet the knife line on the face and on the edge, with the line still visible on the part's side?
  • Is the cut square, checked with the square on two faces, not by eye?
  • Did you use the crosscut edge for cuts across the grain and the rip edge for cuts along it?
  • For a cut that wandered, can you say which way and whether the wander repeated?
  • Are rough parts at least about 1 in over length and 1/4 in over width, so the plane and the finished cut have something to remove?

Worked example

Noor (fictional) saws five crosscuts in a 1x6 offcut on her bench hook. The first two meet the line on top and drift about 1/32 in toward the waste on the bottom face, both the same way. Her square shows the saw leaning. She moves to stand at the end of the table, with her eye over the blade, and saws the third in stages. It is square on both faces, and so are the fourth and fifth. The drift changed when her stance changed, so it was technique, not the saw. Her practice sheet reads: two leaning, three square, cause stance. That meets the Done when: the last cuts meet the line on both faces, checked with the square, and she makes two more square in a row the next evening to bring the run to five.

Common mistakes

  • Sawing on the line. The part loses half a kerf. Put the kerf in the waste.
  • Forcing the saw. More pressure bends a thin plate off line. Let the teeth do it.
  • Ripping with the crosscut edge, or crosscutting with the rip edge. Check the grain, not the word "length" or "height" on the cut list.
  • Correcting a wander halfway by twisting the saw. The plate binds and the cut becomes a curve. Stop, start a fresh kerf on the line from the other face, and meet it.
  • Cutting finished lengths before planing. The plane then has nothing to take off the ends, and any wander is in the finished part.
  • Blaming your hands for a bad saw. If the drift repeats whatever you change, test the saw against another one.

What is still unresolved

11. Knowledge check and scenario

Noor's tote ends are cut with the grain running up and down. Is cutting them to 10 1/2 in tall a rip or a crosscut?
A crosscut. The cut runs across the fibers, whatever the part's drawing calls that dimension. Use the crosscut edge.
Why does the kerf go on the waste side of the line?
The kerf is wood turned to dust, a little under 1/32 in on one maker's tenon saw. Sawing down the middle of the line takes half of it from the part; sawing beside the line on the waste side leaves the part its full size.
Your cuts drift to the left every time, whether you saw fast or slow, standing at the side or the end. What do you suspect, and how do you test it?
The saw: uneven set, teeth duller on one side, or a bent plate. Make the same cut with another saw. If the drift disappears, the first saw needs a new blade or a sharpener.
Why rough-cut parts 1 in over length and 1/4 in over width first?
So planing and the finished cut have material to remove, and a rough cut that wanders does no harm. Glen Huey of Popular Woodworking uses those allowances.
(Go deeper) Why can a pull saw's plate be thinner than a push saw's?
On the pull stroke the plate is in tension, which keeps it straight. A thin plate pushed from behind would buckle, so a Western saw needs a thicker plate or a spine.
Your third crosscut is square on the top face but out by about 1/16 in on the bottom face. The first two were fine. What do you do?
Two good cuts and one bad one is not a saw's pattern; a saw problem repeats. Test the saw only if the drift keeps coming back the same way whatever you change.
A one-off lean is usually technique. Sawing in stages lets the top kerf guide the rest, and checking early catches a lean while it is shallow. Log the cut on the practice sheet so a pattern shows if one develops.
On a rough cut with an inch to spare, that is fine. On a finished length, 1/16 in out is more than a shooting board takes off comfortably, and the part may end up short.

Checklist

Records your learning only; it is not a qualification.